There was slight European hangover for Celtic as they drew 0-0 against a spirited Livingston side on a frustrating afternoon at the Toni Macaroni Arena.

Celtic took a while to find their rhythm against their well-organised opponents but after the opening half hour, some chances did come and go.

Ryan Christie found his way past some challenges and got his shot away in the box with Tom Rogic firing over on the rebound from Kelly’s save.

Livi’s best chance of finding the net looked to be from corners with Scott Bain having to tip over a couple of headers from Declan Gallagher over the bar before the break.

Dolly Menga was lucky to stay on the pitch after appearing to throw his head into Ryan Christie.

The Hosts continued to make life difficult into the second half with. Celtic struggling to break them down.

Bain missed a flick on a Livi long throw almost giving Craig Halkett a chance but there were few defensive scares.

At the other end, Rogic drew a flying save from Kelly from a powerful effort with five minutes to go.

Celtic pressed for a late winner but lacked any great creativity and ultimate didn’t deserve anything more than a point which does, however, see them go back to the top of the Premiership table.

Here’s how we rated the Celtic players after the match.