Celtic looked out of ideas and laboured to a goalless draw against Dundee at Paradise.

Patrick Roberts was the only bright spark in the first half and looked to create something for Celtic.

His run inside three minutes was almost capped off with a goal but saw his shot well block by the Dundee defender.

Leigh Griffiths was presented with the best chance of the half after the Dees ‘keeper missed the ball but couldn’t compose himself to shoot and saw the ball cleared for a corner.

The first shot in the second half came on the 75th minute for Celtic as Mulgrew saw his shot fantastically saved.

Dundee had the best chance of the game with seven minutes remaining but Kostadin Gadzhalov somehow failed to hit the target.

Here are the player ratings from tonight’s game.

Stu Forster/Getty Images Sport Start slideshow