Matthew MacDermid has been appointed referee for Celtic’s Premiership meeting with St Mirren at Celtic Park on Saturday, November 21.
And given what happened the last time he found himself at the centre of a major Celtic controversy, supporters have every right to ask questions.
The Scottish FA’s refereeing appointments confirm MacDermid will take charge, with Greg Aitken on VAR and Ross Hardie assisting.
Another match. Another set of officials.
And another opportunity for the SFA to demonstrate that lessons have actually been learned.
Because Celtic supporters have heard enough explanations after the damage has already been done.
Celtic haven’t forgotten the Hibernian controversy
Cast your mind back to February 22.
Celtic were beaten 2-1 by Hibernian in a match overshadowed by controversial refereeing decisions.
MacDermid dismissed Auston Trusty following a VAR review of an off-the-ball incident involving Jamie McGrath.
Celtic appealed the red card, but the SFA rejected their appeal.
However, that wasn’t the only major talking point.
Liam Scales was subsequently pulled inside the penalty area by Hibernian defender Jack Iredale.
No penalty.
No intervention from VAR.
Nothing.
Martin O’Neill later revealed that MacDermid had explained the holding hadn’t lasted long enough to justify a penalty.
Seriously?
Since when did the duration of a foul become the deciding factor?
Willie Collum admitted Celtic were wronged
And here’s where the argument becomes impossible to dismiss as simply another complaint from Celtic supporters.
Willie Collum, the SFA’s head of refereeing, subsequently acknowledged that Celtic should have received a penalty.
The incident was examined through the SFA’s VAR Review programme.
Collum accepted that the challenge on Scales warranted a spot-kick and that VAR should have recommended an on-field review.
The Scotsman reported the subsequent assessment of the Celtic-Hibernian decisions.
So this wasn’t simply a disputed decision.
The people responsible for overseeing Scottish refereeing acknowledged that a significant mistake had been made.
And what did Celtic get?
An explanation.
Not the penalty. Not the opportunity to change the match.
Just another admission after the final whistle.
Celtic deserve accountability, not excuses
Let’s be absolutely clear.
I’m not accusing MacDermid of deliberately making decisions against Celtic. There is no evidence to justify that.
But I am questioning the system that allows serious mistakes to occur and then expects supporters to move on after another review.
We have VAR.
We have multiple officials.
We have cameras covering virtually every angle.
And still we find ourselves discussing decisions that the SFA subsequently acknowledges were wrong.
What exactly are Celtic and every other Scottish club paying for?
Where is the accountability?
Where are the measurable improvements?
And why should supporters have confidence that the same mistakes won’t happen again?
The SFA must answer for its standards
MacDermid has also refereed Celtic victories this season, which demonstrates that not every appointment ends in controversy.
But that doesn’t erase what happened against Hibernian.
Nor does it remove the responsibility of the SFA to ensure that its officials consistently apply the laws of the game.
Martin O’Neill’s players should be concentrating on beating St Mirren.
Supporters should be looking forward to the football.
Instead, previous officiating failures have left legitimate questions hanging over another appointment.
The SFA appoints the referees. The SFA reviews their performances. The SFA must take responsibility when its system fails.
Celtic aren’t asking for special treatment.
They’re asking for competent, consistent and accountable officiating.
Surely that isn’t too much to expect.
Key takeaways
- Matthew MacDermid will referee Celtic against St Mirren on Saturday, November 21.
- Greg Aitken has been appointed VAR, with Ross Hardie assisting.
- MacDermid dismissed Auston Trusty against Hibernian following a VAR review in February.
- Willie Collum subsequently acknowledged Celtic should have received a penalty for the challenge on Liam Scales.
- The SFA must demonstrate that lessons have been learned from previous officiating mistakes.
Further reading
- Celtic’s 2005 deal raises questions for shareholders
- Celtic top, Rangers second: Pundits’ title talk