Celtic’s European decline is becoming a story far beyond Scotland. After the 2-1 defeat by Celta Vigo, the international reaction made uncomfortable reading for anyone who remembers what this club once represented.
The Daily Record’s world media round-up gathered verdicts from Spain, France and the United States. Different voices described the same damaging picture: Celtic took the lead, lost control and had little answer when the game turned.
For me, the most troubling part is how familiar that assessment has become.
European reaction exposes Celtic’s weaknesses
Spanish coverage celebrated Javi Rodríguez’s decisive double, but several reports also questioned Celtic’s ability to respond.
La Voz de Galicia highlighted Celta’s superiority and the impact of Claudio Giráldez’s substitutions. Meanwhile, Faro de Vigo described Celtic falling back on crosses as the visitors protected their advantage.
That should sting. Celtic Park is supposed to unsettle opponents. Increasingly, visiting teams seem confident that their organisation and technical quality will carry them through.
The French assessment, attributed to L’Équipe in the round-up, focused on another collapse and Celtic’s failure to collect a point from their opening three league-phase fixtures.
These were not Scottish pundits searching for an argument. They were overseas observers assessing what unfolded in front of them.
Joy questions the squad’s European ambition
The sharpest criticism came from Ian Paul Joy on CBS Sports Golazo.
According to the Record’s report, Joy argued that Celtic’s squad had been assembled for domestic success rather than the demands of European football. He also questioned the expertise behind recruitment and expressed sympathy for Martin O’Neill.
His closing question cut through: “Where’s that pride gone from Celtic Football Club?”
It is a fair question. However, sympathy for the manager should not remove scrutiny of his decisions. Celtic still have to defend set pieces, manage momentum and react when opponents change the contest.
At the same time, responsibility stretches beyond the dugout. If recruitment repeatedly leaves the team short at this level, those directing the club must answer for it.
Celtic need answers beyond domestic comfort
Winning in Scotland cannot keep providing cover for disappointment abroad.
Celtic have the stadium, the support and a European history that deserves more than nostalgic references whenever another defeat arrives.
Nobody is demanding a return to 1967 overnight. We are entitled to demand a coherent plan, credible recruitment and visible progress.
The international verdict should embarrass those running Celtic. More importantly, it should force them to explain how they intend to change it.
If Celtic had beaten LASC to qualify for the CL proper what kind of disastrous results would have been afflicted on the club and team at the top level ? Obviously Celtic cannot compete at the Europa League level presently so what kind of humiliating scores would the best of the best teams have dished out ? Sadly the rank rotten European form and quality cannot be sorted out over a wet weekend or even a month of practice ! This is chronic ….and it feels worse when an £11 million pounds new player gets dropped comes on as a substitute runs around like a headless chicken and could not score in a Bordello ! There is much to be concerned about and to add insult to injury those smarmy snide scoops of the SMSM are having a field day in their criticism and enjoyment of it all as it happens . Eating it all up like pigs in shit in a pen !
I normally DETEST The Scummy Scottish Football Media but if you are reporting that that they’re giving it to Celtic and the board especially then hey ho The Scummy’s then bring it on !
You’re right my friend, it is chronic. It’s also a very Scottish/Irish, insular way of looking at things that have brought us to this position, both by our Board and our Management. We’re in danger of becoming a Scottish version of Manchester United whereby we pay these inflated prices for guys who are bang average, throw them alongside some guys who are arguably worse than bang average, and expect them to play like a decent side in Europe. It ain’t gonna happen under the current regime. If we don’t watch out, it might not even happen in Scotland for much longer. Amongst all the analysis last night and before, I never once heard any criticism of Calum McGregor. It’s like he’s the first name on the teamsheet without any critical analysis of what he does and doesn’t bring to the team. He’s been past it for at least a couple of years, and because he’s not even considered past it by our current Management, our woeful style of play, which has to go through him, is predictable and our inability to win against average sides in europe is now the norm. When he’s not being easily man-marked by anyone who can simply run, the play is going through him and he’s passing the buck (usually sideways or backwards) and moving into space where he can’t receive the ball. I don’t doubt for a second that if Askou had gotten the job at Celtic, he would have replaced him. To give McGregor credit where it’s due, he’s been a great servant but everyone has their day and time catches up with us all. If he has Celtic’s interest at heart, he’d do the decent thing and leave, much in the same way as to why he gave up international duty. Also, to be fair to McGregor, there are several others who should be nowhere near a Celtic jersey.
Sadly, I think this season will bring things to a crescendo at Celtic and something will give. It’s self-evident that our Board and Management do not see what’s happening on the pitch through the same eyes as we do. Wholesale change is needed at Celtic and it’s looking like we may need to take several steps backwards before it changes direction. Our current custodians unfortunately won’t sack themselves so it would look like a buy-out, if at all possible, might be the only option for a change of direction. That may only become an option if our ‘Owner’ and Board are driven to it. As an ex-season ticket holder, I say to all our season ticket holders, it’s not easy to give it up but ask yourself this question: what’s your alternative? because the way I see it, the alternative is not only more of the same in Europe, it’s also potential to decline in Scotland. Last point. Remember my comment above about Manchester United. Full stadiums, loyal fanbase, success at home and abroad? Who would they command a decent fee for if they put him up for sale? We are winning at home. At the moment, anyway. Apart from that, are we any different? Loyalty is one thing but being taken for a mug is another. I’ve no regrets about giving up my season ticket and the fact that someone else is in my seat, only means that there is more that needs convincing. Trust me, it’s not the end of the world and I’d sooner use the money for a better cause than our corporate fat cat, self-serving board and owner that doesn’t give a flying fu** about our great fans and just laugh all the way to the bank at your expense.
Because it’s Friday and i’ve still got a sense of humour, McGregor will probably win ballon d’or, we’ll win the Europa League, and DD will issue a personal apology to all fans adding that he told you so. Hail Hail.
This incompetent Board should explain to the Celtic Supporters why year after year there has been no net expenditure on playing staff.
Absolutely unacceptable.