02.03.2016. Celtic Park, Glasgow, Scotland. Scottish Premier League. Celtic versus Dundee. Celtic sign illuminated before the match with Dundee
Yesterday, I reported that Hugh Keevins has started relying on fan media for his Sunday morning content.
Today, it’s the turn of his employers.
Because the Daily Record are now getting their Celtic transfer news from a Celtic fan media website.
You couldn’t make it up.
Or could you?
Saturday’s Record article on Simon Ebonog and Gvidas Gineitis names Celts are Here as its source
The Record piece was all about Celtic shaking up the midfield in January.
It says Martin O’Neill is likely to recruit there once the window opens.
Fair enough, that’s hardly a state secret.
But when it came to Ebonog, here is how the Record put it:
Celts are Here report he is being tracked closely ahead of a potential January bid although it’s understood they are yet to formalise their interest in the 22-year-old.
That’s the Le Havre midfielder they are talking about.
And where did they get it from?
And the source for the story isn’t a contact at the club, or an agent, or a journalist in France.
It’s a Celtic fan media site.
A Celtic fan media site – the very people the SMSM spend half their time sneering at.
The Gineitis half of the story came from TuttoMercato in Italy, which at least is a proper outlet.
But the one that matters, the one about Celtic’s own January plans, came from us.
Now, I’m not having a go at Celts are Here.
Good on them for getting the story out there.
They did the work and they should get the credit.
My issue is with the title that used to sell hundreds of thousands of copies every single day.
A newspaper that can’t find its own Celtic transfer stories has no business calling itself a newspaper
The Record have form when it comes to dodgy sources, mind you.
In the past, they used that notorious bullshit site Football Insider.
But such was the ridicule they took for it, from sites like this one, they never did it again.
So credit where it’s due, they can learn.
Just not very quickly.
And they have apparently decided that a fan media website is a safer bet than a site that makes things up.
I’d say that tells you everything.
It also tells you why a paper that once sold hundreds of thousands of copies a day is now a fraction of that.
Readers aren’t daft.
They know when they’re being served a rehash, and they know where to go instead.
Fan media is now a more credible source for club news than the mainstream media
And it isn’t just the Ebonog story.
Look at the Charlie Methven interview on ACSOM and The Celtic Exchange.
That took it to another level.
An interview like that was the kind of scoop every sports editor in Scotland dreams of.
And to be fair to Keevins, you could tell from his column that he had his nose pressed against the window from outside.
He wanted that scoop.
He just didn’t have the contacts, or the nerve, to go and get it.
So he waited a week and wrote about it instead.
That is what passes for journalism in the Scottish mainstream sports media these days.
Wait for fan media to do the work, then wait for the weekend, then dress it up as your own.
There is no journalistic endeavour whatsoever in it.
And who exactly is that supposed to fool?
Celtic supporters know where to go for their news now, because they know who they can trust
That is the part the SMSM can’t stand.
The happy clappers hate it too.
Every time a fan media site breaks a story, they come out of the woodwork.
But as I’ve said enough times in the past few weeks, if they want to report their own stories, they should start their own blogs and their own podcasts.
Nobody is stopping them.
Instead, they sit in the shadows and take potshots at those of us who actually do it.
And they MISS.
Every single time.
Having said that, I’ll concede one thing.
Being the go-to destination for Celtic news is not a role any of us set out to fill.
We didn’t want it.
We just got tired of waiting for someone else to do it.
When it comes to the Scottish mainstream sports media, it really is a case of how the mighty have fallen
There was a time when a back page splash in the Record could set the agenda for the entire week.
Now they’re lifting their transfer stories from supporters with a keyboard and a microphone.
And they don’t even see the irony.
Will it change?
Not a chance.
Not until they learn the art of real journalism.
Which, it seems, has been dead in Scotland for quite some time now…
I rest my case.
Key Takeaways
- Hugh Keevins now relies on fan media for content, while the Daily Record uses fan sources for Celtic transfer news.
- The Record’s article on transfers cites a Celtic fan media site as a source, raising questions about journalistic integrity.
- Fan media has become a more credible source for club news compared to mainstream outlets, which now often rehash fan-generated content.
- Celtic supporters increasingly trust fan media, as mainstream journalists fail to produce original stories.
- The decline of Scottish mainstream sports media reflects a shift in how Celtic fans access and value their news.
Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.