Daniel Cummings scored 39 goals in 62 appearances for Celtic’s B team. His reward? One brief first-team appearance before leaving for West Ham United.
Now, the 20-year-old striker has joined National League side Aldershot Town on loan.
Some will undoubtedly point to that move as evidence that Cummings made a mistake leaving Celtic.
I see something entirely different.
I see another talented young footballer who was never given a meaningful opportunity to prove himself at Celtic Park.
And perhaps the bigger question is why this keeps happening.
Celtic’s academy pathway needs serious scrutiny
According to Inside Futbol’s latest report, Aldershot manager Scott Davies has praised Cummings’ aggression, work rate and instinct for finding dangerous positions.
This is hardly a young man whose career deserves to be written off.
Indeed, West Ham’s official player profile confirms that Cummings scored 29 goals in 37 appearances during his final season with Celtic’s B team.
Yet his only senior appearance came against Aston Villa in January 2025.
Was that really enough to assess his potential?
Nobody is suggesting that Cummings should have walked straight into Celtic’s starting eleven.
But surely a striker producing those numbers deserved a genuine opportunity.
Chris McCart must answer some difficult questions
Chris McCart has been involved with Celtic’s academy for more than two decades.
According to Celtic’s own academy staff directory, he has held a senior academy leadership position for over twelve years.
That is a considerable period of responsibility.
So I think it is entirely reasonable to ask what Celtic are achieving in terms of developing established first-team players.
Look at the names supporters regularly mention.
Callum McGregor. James Forrest. Kieran Tierney. Anthony Ralston.
Excellent footballers, every one of them.
But how many academy graduates have established themselves as regular Celtic starters over the past twenty years?
There have been other graduates, including Stephen Welsh, Mikey Johnston and several promising youngsters.
Nevertheless, the number who have become long-term first-team fixtures remains remarkably limited.
McCart should be able to explain the academy’s performance against measurable targets.
However, this responsibility cannot rest on his shoulders alone.
What is the point of developing talent if successive first-team managers are reluctant to use it?
Celtic cannot keep blocking their own youngsters
Cummings is hardly an isolated case.
Ben Doak, Rocco Vata and Daniel Kelly also left Celtic while still young.
Their circumstances differed, but each departure raised questions about opportunities and long-term development.
Former Celtic defender Rudi Vata has publicly criticised the club’s approach to young players, arguing that his son Rocco lacked a convincing pathway into the senior side.
And that should concern everyone at Celtic.
Because an academy cannot simply exist to produce promising footballers for somebody else.
It must have a clear connection to the first team.
Colby Donovan proves opportunities matter
Colby Donovan and Dane Murray offer encouragement.
Both have shown that young players can contribute when opportunities arrive.
Martin O’Neill has also spoken positively about Liam Kennedy and Sean McArdle.
But individual success stories are not a substitute for a properly functioning development strategy.
Celtic should publish clear targets for academy progression, establish meaningful development plans and ensure that exceptional young players receive opportunities.
Not guaranteed starting positions.
Not sentimental selections.
Proper opportunities to demonstrate whether they belong.
Daniel Cummings is only 20. His career is beginning, not ending.
I hope his loan spell gives him the senior football he needs to flourish.
But Celtic should be asking themselves a far more uncomfortable question.
If a young striker scores 39 goals and still cannot earn a meaningful run of first-team opportunities, what message does that send to every talented teenager at Lennoxtown?
The problem is not Daniel Cummings leaving Celtic.
The problem is that Celtic keep giving talented youngsters reasons to believe their futures lie somewhere else.
Related Read Celtic articles
- Celtic’s youth void – are we actually building a pathway?
- Rudi Vata’s damning indictment of the Celtic youth system
Key takeaways
- Daniel Cummings scored 39 goals in 62 Celtic B appearances but made only one senior appearance.
- Chris McCart has held a senior academy leadership role for more than twelve years.
- Celtic have produced talented graduates, but relatively few have become long-term first-team regulars.
- The academy, first-team management and board must share responsibility for creating a genuine pathway.
- Celtic need measurable development targets and meaningful opportunities for deserving youngsters.