Craig Williamson - SNS Group/SNS Group/Getty Images
You will note that I was markedly absent from all the mayhem of the last day of Celtic’s transfer window.
If I’m being honest, every blogger is clamouring for the same stories on deadline day, so I personally don’t see the point to adding nothing new to what anybody else does.
Instead, I sat back and watched the machinations of the final day closely.
It flattered to decieve.
That’s my honest opinion.
Before the window ever opened, a lot of emphasis was put on trimming an over bloated squad.
This particular subject is something I’ve always questioned.
For a board that is so apparently frugal when it comes to finance, I could never understand why they always allowed us to have such an over-bloated squad.
The amount of wages that were paid, and wasted, in 2023/24 on players who contributed nothing to the first team squad, must have been off the scale?
I think the James McCarthy scenario is one that grates the most.
For 3 years, McCarthy earned a substantial wage at Celtic.

In return, he gave us 12 appearances.
Good business for the best run club in Britain?
I’ll let you be the judge of that.
However, returning to the subject at hand, departures in the summer transfer window, I think its fair to say our over-bloated squad has been well trimmed.
As ever with our board, they can never seem to find the happy medium.
We needed to trim the squad.
Not wipe it out.
This summer’s trimming has resulted in a now threadbare squad.
But I’m pretty sure the board got high on the fumes of cash-savings as more, and more players headed for the exit doors.
Its almost as if someone suddenly had an epiphany and realised that an over-bloated squad with players contributing nothing could result in huge cash-savings if trimmed.
Or culled, whichever way you want to look at it.
Because make no mistake, this Celtic squad was culled.
The departure of Tomoki Iwata to Birmingham City on loan yesterday left our midfield, despite the addition of two more midfielders, very exposed.

Three potential first team midfielders in O’Riley, Iwata, and Kwan are now gone from the club.
From the B team, Daniel Kelly, and Bosun Lawal were sold.
Five midfielders in total.
Our back-up striker in Hyeon-gyu Oh was sold to Belgian side Genk.
He was not replaced.
Celtic now has six first team midfielders.
Meaning that each first-team starter only has one back up.
We have just two first team strikers.
One has a crocked shoulder, which will eventually have to be operated on.
The other has yet to settle back in since his return to the club, but I’m sure Adam Idah will.
Tomorrow is the perfect opportunity to signal his return with a bang.
Idah came up with the goods against the Ibrox side last season, let’s hope he does it again tomorrow.

I’m sure we can also be consoled by the fact we have Daizen Maeda as a back up striker, if required.
But the manager clearly stated that he wanted another striker.
There were plenty of options available out there, well within our budget.
Purchasing one would probably still have resulted in us finishing with a player trading surplus.
I won’t dwell all day on how threadbare our squad actually is, but suffice it to say, if we are hit with an injury crisis similar to the magnitude of the one we witnessed last year, I dread to think of the impact it will have.
We don’t really even have first team ready players to step up from the B team in the event of a bad run of injuries.
With the exception of Francis Turley, I don’t think there are many other options available to us.
We sold those that could have contributed.
I think Vata, Lawal, and Kelly would have been very valuable to first team if they were still here.
But they’re not, so we just have to accept that.
So, while the hierarchy may feel the departures lounge has been an overwhelming success in this summer’s window, I can’t really say that I echo those sentiments.
Only time, and a long arduous season, with extra Champions League games, will tell.

As for the incomings?
I will admit that I’m excited to see what Arne Engels will bring to the table.
There is no doubting that this guy is a talent.
He is young, was already a well established player in the Bundesliga, and is soon to be a Belgian International.
Taking all of that into account, his sell on value, if he is a success, is likely to be very lucrative for the club.
However, let’s hope we’re not having a conversation about that for another three years or so, at least.
Luke McGowan is another one to watch, I think.
I’ve been very impressed with his contribution as Dundee skipper.
Last season, he played very well, and helped his side to a top 6 finish, with plenty of goals and assists along the way.
There’s no disputing he’ll be able to tear it up in the Scottish Premiership, especially when he’s surrounded by players of the calibre he’ll be playing with a Celtic.
Under the tutelage of Brendan Rodgers, he will get the opportunity to take his game to the next level.
I don’t know, but I have a sneaking suspicion we might have a very long term Celtic servant on our hands in the form of McGowan, if all goes well.

Auston Trusty also looks like a good acquisition.
The fact that he and CCV are USMNT team-mates, and very familiar with each other, can only auger well for our central defence going forward.
So, all in all, I cannot say I’m disappointed with our deadline day acquistions.
But, there’s always a but, you say, while the quality of these players is high, and they are first team ready players, there is no doubting we could have done more for the manager.
He wanted another striker, he didn’t get one.
He wanted another winger, he didn’t get one either.
I suppose we should be somewhat thankful that James Forrest is experiencing something of a renaissance at the ripe old age of 33.
The age-old left back conundrum is as yet unsolved.
Unless, of course, Alex Valle turns out to be a revelation and we pursue him when his loan ends.

But that option does not appear to be on the table as yet.
Despite the fact there is a €3 million buy-out clause in his contract.
In the case of Adam Idah, we learned a hard lesson there.
Taking a player without a loan to buy option, who then becomes a resounding success, just means that when he returns to his parent club, they can hike up his price as they see fit.
Lesson one, the club needs to learn from that fiasco, and they should not allow it to happen again.
When Idah came on loan, he was valued at £6 million.
You know what we paid for him, so this particular story speaks for itself.
Lesson two, why, when you have almost three months of a transfer window, would you wait until the last day of said window to get your business done?
Once again, for a club that is so frugal with it’s finances, this way of operating makes no financial sense.
As has been discussed ad-nauseam by Celtic fan media, when you start negotiating for players in the last few days of the window, clubs can name their price.
They can do this, because they know you’re desperate to get deals tied up before the window shuts.
And while the board will spin this window as a resounding success, the reality is an entirely different scenario.
They will state that they broke the club’s transfer record not once, but twice.

All well and good, until you look at that forensically.
They low-balled Norwich with a £4.5 million bid for Idah.
It is clear this insulted Norwich, who in return jacked up Idah’s asking price significantly.
The manager made it crystal clear he wanted the player.
The board had to get him.
The opening bid should have been £6 million.
Since that’s what Norwich had valued him at before he came to Celtic.
The fact that he was a resounding success, and a huge contributing factor to our double winning season, meant his value would appreciate, rather than depreciate.
And that is the way Norwich would have seen it.
However, the money men at our club somehow thought he had gone down in value by offering an opening bid of £4.5 million for him.
Bad move – transfer record broken.
Lesson number three – Don’t lowball.
With regard to Arne Engels, this scenario speaks for itself.
Last two days of the window, Augsburg could name their price.

They squeezed every last red penny they could out of us.
And no doubt, inserted a generous sell on clause too.
So the real lesson here is this; maybe utilise the time available to you in a lengthy transfer window to get deals done early, rather than last minute.com?
Then it might not end up costing you as much as it did.
And you might not have the breaking of club transfer records enforced upon you either.
It worked pretty well for Ange Postecoglou in his first two windows here.
Especially in the second.
So why did nobody pay any attention to that?
I guess only the people within the Celtic boardroom know the answer to that one.

The big question here is will they learn anything from this transfer window?
Or will we just get more of the same in January again?
I’m not even going to try and predict it.
There wouldn’t be any point.
Chances are I’ll hit the nail on the head anyway.
And I’d rather not piss myself off just yet by doing that.
My overall impressions of the window just closed?
Let’s just say I’m glad its over with.
This will be my last blog on it.
There’s an important game on tomorrow, and that’s what I want to talk about from here on out.
Would I say it was a successful window?
Without needing to elaborate on it, I said what I thought of it in this blog.
That should be enough.
I’ll leave it at that.
As you say, people will have differing views on the window in terms of good vs bad. I go along with most of your take on it. I said a long time ago that the club needed to do what they did when Ange was manager. It was certainly better than the more recent ones. Time will tell right enough. Interesting season ahead for sure HH
Wondering when you would stick your head up out of your misery swamp Eric. You will be out of a job soon eh? All this positive news terrible for a perennial ‘sack ra board’ whiner like yourself I imagine, whose USP is extended howls of delusion to appease the lower brow members of the Celtic support. Those for whom the bottle of Buckfast is always half empty. Written irritatingly in your hallmark style of very few syllables and Ladybird book sentences.
I can safely tell you I won’t be out of a job any time soon, Brian. In fact, the people above me are so happy with my ladybird style of writing, they are offering me other Celtic avenues to cover. When you’re not a happy clapper and tell the truth, as it should be told, that’s the end result. So, while I enjoy your board loving rants, I’m afraid you’re going to have to continue to put up with my rants re our board’s failings. Sorry to disappoint😁
Brian McAllister
says:
31st August 2024 at 2:03 pm
Wondering when you would stick your head up out of your misery swamp Eric. You will be out of a job soon eh? All this positive news terrible for a perennial ‘sack ra board’ whiner like yourself I imagine, whose USP is extended howls of delusion to appease the lower brow members of the Celtic support. Those for whom the bottle of Buckfast is always half empty. Written irritatingly in your hallmark style of very few syllables and Ladybird book sentences.
————-
Brian
There are loads of sites for huns like yourself to infest.
I imagine you will be delighted with how the window went for Celtic because it leaves the club short in key areas like a class winger to compete in Champions League.
Brian, tell me how you felt when your old club died in 2012?
You make some good points but you also make signing players sound as if it’s a completely one sided thing, that everything is in Celtic’s gift to make happen.
What if Augsburg had other clubs interested in the player and told Celtic they’d need to wait until the last week?
What if the players agent said to Celtic that they’d hang off and see what other offers materialise?
Augsburg signed a midfielder at the last minute, did they say to us, sorry no deal until we know we have a replacement coming in?.
How do you know we offered £4.5m for Idah? Paper talk, no more, no less.
How do you get an option to buy if the loaning club decide not to offer one? Do you walk away because you don’t have that option or take a chance?
In summary, I agree with the frustrations about how we do business but to look at it as simply as Celtic being in full control of the discussions, process and outcomes misses reality.
As to the original question, is it a good window? I thought the 10IAR window was a belter, Duffy, Laxalt,.Elyouonoussi etc. We all saw how that turned out so like you, I’ll judge it in twelve months time, not today.
1000000% Agree with Brian Mcallister. I had hidden Read Celtic from my news aggregator until I saw an article recently as was on a new device. Enjoyed it and therefore made eure I could see all articles.
Since then it hss been and endless stream of misery from Eric regarding the team he “loves.” Life is too tough already without being subjected to incessant whining about a team I adore. Very good point from Brian regarding writing skills as Eric comes off a self important and a bit of a knob at the same time.
Oh well, lesson learned. Back to the hiding all articles from this guy and Read Celtic too, which is zero loss at all to be fair.
Good article, although I don’t necessarily agree with all of it. In my humble opinion, it’s been a good window, although not happy that it was left as late. Wanted 2 main strikers and an academy player to come through, he got that. Wanted 2 midfielders to replace MOR, got them. Wanted a left centre half and left back, check and check. New goalie, got a first teamer and a promising backup. Wanted a new winger but did we honestly need one? Lawal, Kelly, Iwata, Kwon, were they ever going to get ahead of CalMac, Paulo, Reo, Arne, Holm, McCowan, I don’t think so. Overall, as mentioned in the article, time will tell but I’m personally happy with the squad and excited for the season. On a side note, as a few supporters have mentioned, the two early business windows of Ange happened when Mr Lawwell wasn’t at the club, is that a factor??
In terms of o’reilly we knew he was gonna go, iwata was semi regular last season, other than that Kelly had around 6 games and the other 2 were out on loan, we have essentially replaced 2 1st team midfielders with 2 1st team midfielders so no worse off in terms of numbers, bear in mind as well these midfielders other than o’reilly will have only been sold with the managers blessing I’m pretty sure on that rather than this being a board decision, as per lb situation valle has a 3m release clause so no need for an obligation there as they cannot jack the price up above the release clause anyway, I enjoy your writing when it’s measured but you do talk some nonsense when you try fit stuff in to feed the board do everything wrong mantra, personally I think it’s been a good window, o’reilly was always gonna go and we’ve cleared the deadwood from the squad, finally got real financially with a couple big signings as well, undoubtedly we could have done a bit more but no doubt fans of every club will say that, as for leaving transfers until the last minute a large number of deals get done in last few days of the window, always have and always will, not as easy as going out and buying everyone you want as soon as the window opens unfortunately, only real gripe for me is no extra winger brought in, ideally a bit more quality out there would have been great.
Really? How can ANYONE seriously find fault at this transfer window action by the club?
They were brilliant!
We went in knowing there was a 90%+ chance that Matt O’Riley was going to be gone by the end of August. But we were determined that it would be on the full terms of the club. We would get OUR valuation. We would not get undervalued.
We received full value.
We held on to EVERY other key player.
We then went to capture our targets and succeeded with every one of them. The one from LA who was an additional target was quickly dropped when we realized that his club tried playing hardball with the wrong people.
HAIL HAIL TO THE BEST RUN CLUB IN BRITAIN
Joe
We got everyone of our targets?? Don’t talk shite. There is a real stench of board plant wafting from you.
So many of these “so called” Celtic fans sites really just feed the moon howlers. All click bait for the brain dead amateur account / businessman. The board this, the board that ,.. When in reality, posters have absolute zero knowledge of anything involving running a football club / business. I would bet large % that are always moaning / posting about the board probably go to less than 5 games a year / if any at all. Because they buy a counterfeit Celtic top they think there opinion matters . Modern football is about money, which dictates having solid business plan.. not letting emotions influence your approach. “ALL” members of our board could walk away tomorrow & get better paid jobs. I know for average workers ( especially Scotland) there salary / bonuses sound a lot …BUT ITS NOT . Celtic have to pay similar to London or we simply will not get strong candidates “that we need “. . They are not paid to please fans, they are paid to build for future .( Future, does not mean next season)
Wow Mark, how you presume to know me when you actually know fuck all about me. It’s kind of hard to attend games from a different country, considering I don’t live in Scotland, but I travel to at least 4 to 5 games a year at a cost that far exceeds the cost of a season ticket. Outside of that, I attend my CSC without fail for every game with all the other ex-pat Glaswegian lads. I’ve supported Celtic for 40+ years, and there’s very little I don’t know about the club’s history. I’ll put this simply to you, our board lacks ambition when it comes to Europe. Our record in this theatre in the 21st century is abysmal. It is clear Brendan Rodgers is attempting to drag the board kicking and screaming into the 21st century, but it isn’t proving an easy task. You cannot dispute any of what I’m saying when it comes to Europe. I want our club to do better in Europe. Why? Because I know it can do better if the ambition was there. There are European clubs out there with far smaller resources and budgets than ours who consistently punch above their weight in Europe. Even our noisy neighbours have done it. There is no reason we can’t. But our board holds us back in this area. If I see an improvement this season, then I will give credit where it is due, but I still think we are ill prepared going into the Champions League this season, and a bad run of injuries will prove me right on that score. But Mark, don’t assume to know something about someone when you haven’t a clue. I’ll leave it at that.
It was an acceptable window. O’Riley was never going to be replaced unless a player was signed for 20 million, But Engels seems a good shout. I know little about Trusty but Sheff Utd fans I work with say he is garbage and are delighted to get 6 million for him. Kelly and Vata should not have been allowed to go but were both not confident of ever getting a chance. Cant blame them.
CamdenNW1
says:
31st August 2024 at 4:33 pm
So many of these “so called” Celtic fans sites really just feed the moon howlers. All click bait for the brain dead amateur account / businessman. The board this, the board that ,.. When in reality, posters have absolute zero knowledge of anything involving running a football club / business. I would bet large % that are always moaning / posting about the board probably go to less than 5 games a year / if any at all. Because they buy a counterfeit Celtic top they think there opinion matters . Modern football is about money, which dictates having solid business plan.. not letting emotions influence your approach. “ALL” members of our board could walk away tomorrow & get better paid jobs. I know for average workers ( especially Scotland) there salary / bonuses sound a lot …BUT ITS NOT . Celtic have to pay similar to London or we simply will not get strong candidates “that we need “. . They are not paid to please fans, they are paid to build for future .( Future, does not mean next season)
————–
3 words.. deluded board stooge
This was a good transfer window for Celtic.. I have read enough of you over the last few months to pick a few things up!
You are never happy with anything the board at Celtic does. They could have spent 100 million and you would have said it should have been more.
We had an over bloated squad and everyone knew it and now we have trimmed it of the dead wood you are saying we need more players! Do me a favour and try and be happy for a bit cos that was a successful window in terms of getting crap away (exception being O’Reilly) and quality in. You are sounding like a broken record which will make people including myself stop reading these articles in the future. Gee us all peace!!
100% agree. We paid a lot of money and people are making a mess of themselves because of it.
We over-paid.
Easy question: would you rather we have Engels or O’Riley? There’s only one answer to that, not matter if Engels does have lots of potential or not, O’Riley is streets ahead of him at the moment.
We massively overpaid for Idah because we were fixated on his signature.
A good job was done getting players off the books, but we are a bit bare in spots.
The window was acceptable, but I have no idea why people are so excited by it.
Celtic have started this season and go into the first Glasgow Derby weaker than they ended last season, no matter how you look at it, that is the case. No Matt O’Riley and new players not trained with the squad. Breaking the club record twice means squat when the total of those two transfers is lower than you got for one player, MOR. But they think we will be impressed with the record buys. We made a bloody profit again in the window. What the hell are they going to do with all this money.
Eric
The better the support understand the business
side the smaller will be the audience for blogs who concentrate on how poor The Board is.
It would serve everyone well to check how Celtic say how things are done and the responsibilities of Directors and how a business case to spend money actually works.
Only problem might be vast majority of the support are not interested although such an understanding would explain the standard of team that goes on the field of play.
Policy is where it all starts, policy that reflects the circumstances Celt face determines budgets and budgets allow Executives, not Non Executives to do their job.
Jeesis Eric, you get some absolute rockets commenting on here! Reading them really do make you wonder if they are board plants. Well done for hitting the nerve 👌
Eric,letting Iwata go baffles me as he really was our only go to guy when we needed to shore up,and he wasn’t replaced.This will be exploited ruthlessly in Europe.January to do list,a number 6 and a winger.
3-0 against our new rivals, not even at our best and still cruised it. New signings got some game time, that’s how easy it was. Top of the league, zero goals conceded… But what have the board done about Aberdeen’s resurgence?? Absolutely nothing! They should have seen this coming, took their eye off the ball, an absolute insult to the fans who have voluntarily paid their hard earned cash and voluntarily bought merchandise whilst voluntarily attending fixtures. It’s a disgrace. This board has to go before we win the treble this season, and get a whole new board in to win another treble next season.