(Photo by WM Sport Media/Getty Images)
For quite some time now as Celtic fans, we’ve resigned ourselves to the fact that the board will never make the right decisions.
Decisions that put the club first, and their misplaced egos second.
Any right minded boardroom would see this current shambles with Wilfired Nancy for what it is.
It is a gamble that has failed.
A gamble based on what happened with Ange Postecoglou, and grounded in the hope that the end result would be the same.
The Wilfried Nancy project, or gamble, whichever you want to call it, is the polar opposite to what happened with Ange Postecoglou.
Last night confirmed it is an unmitigated disaster.
And last night, the decision should have been made to swiftly end this nightmare.
For both the club, and a manager who is completely out of his depth.
A CEO with a pair of balls would simply have ended this after the final whistle last night.
But we have nobody with balls at Celtic Park, other than a de facto owner who seems to have everyone else’s balls firmly in his grasp.
The fact that it is radio silence as usual from Celtic Park this morning tells you that nobody has the courage to knock this shitshow on the head.
Watching that horror show last night at Fir Park, I was left scratching my head in bewilderment.
I began to wonder if the manager could see what we were seeing from the touch line?
I thought to myself, as Motherwell picked us off on the break time, and time again, that surely Nancy would do something to contain it.
But each time the camera focused in on the Frenchman, he seemed to look as bewildered as everyone else watching what was unfolding.
The only sign of emotion he showed was that sort of nonchalant sniff of his nostrils he does every ten or fifteen seconds.
To put last night into perspective, when your defence is being schooled and ripped asunder by a New Zealand International, you know you’ve hit rock bottom.
And I mean no disrespect to Elijah Just in saying that, who is shaping up to be one of the young players of this season so far.
But this is a guy who has two Danish 3rd and 2nd tier clubs on his CV, along with one Austrian 2nd tier club, before arriving at Motherwell.
The question you’ve got to ask is this; is he as good as he looked last night, or did our shambolic set up make him look a hell of a lot better than he is?
And if I’m being honest, I don’t think it would have mattered who we were playing.
With our defence playing as high as it was up the pitch, a schoolboy team could have exposed us mercilessly.
I was also baffled by the changes Nancy made going into last night’s game.
Celtic had just won two games in a row, amd maybe, just maybe, the beginnings of a winning formula had been discovered.

Nancy decided to drop two players who were pivotal in those wins.
Arne Engels and Luke McCowan.
He replaced them with Paolo Bernardo and Reo Hatate.
Every manager does his homework on his opposition, or at least you would think he does.
Motherwell, under Jens Berthel Askou, play a possession based game with a high press.
Everybody knows that Reo Hatate is totally unsuited to a high pressing opposition.
When players press him, he loses possession easily, is prone to calamitous errors, and more often than not, misplaces his passes.
If Wilfried Nancy knew his opposition, and his own players well enough, he would not have played Reo Hatate last night.
Reo Hatate flourishes when we retain possession for long periods of time.
When he is allowed time on the ball, he can pick out players through precision passes, and neat through balls.
When he is harassed and pressed, just as he was last night, the results are catastrophic.
I’m just a blogger, and I’ve known this for a long time.
In fact, I had an in depth conversation with Joe and James about Hatate around this time a year ago on the Trinity Tims podcast.
That was after we had been harried and harassed in a similar fashion at Ibrox, and lost 3-0.
Liam Scales had also had a performance similar to last night’s at Fir Park.
As for Kaspar Schmeichel?
If his second half blunder doesn’t relegate him to the subs bench, then I don’t know what will.
Which brings me to Saturday’s game against the Ibrox side at Celtic Park.
If, and this is a big if, Michael Nicholson has managed to develop some testicular fortitude in light of last night’s shitshow, then he needs to issue Wilfried Nancy with an ultimatum.
Win at Celtic Park on Saturday against the Ibrox side or its curtains.
Because at this point, when we take into consideration what a mess the Ibrox side was a couple of months ago, to allow them to overtake us in the table is utterly unacceptable.
In the event of that happening, it should be the final nail in Nancy’s coffin.
He will no longer command any respect from the fanbase if we are handed our arses on a plate in our own back yard by the Ibrox side.
If last night was anything to go by, I fear for what lies ahead on Saturday.
Surely Nancy cannot survive a humiliating defeat to a manager who is even more of a rookie than he is?
For once, just for once, can the Celtic board make a call that puts the club first?
Because if we lose on Saturday, his position becomes untenable.
If we retain Nancy after that, and allow him to spend millions in the transfer window, the long term damage could be detrimental.
This man does not grasp what it means to be a Celtic manager.
Nor does he grasp what it takes to win in the Scottish Premiership.
His record to date tells us this much.
He is being schooled by managers who have figured out his set up and his tactics.
It has now become like shooting fish in a barrel.
The overriding emotion from the Celtic players last night at Fir Park was sheer frustration.

That frustration stems from being forced to play a system that they know in their hearts is tearing them apart.
They know they are better than this, and that by being forced to take part in this vanity project of Nancy’s, it is causing them reputational damage.
This is the kind of behaviour that loses a dressing room.
If it hasn’t already been lost, that is.
Well, I’ll put it this way, if we lose at home on Saturday, Nancy has lost the respect of everyone.
The dressing room, the fanbase, and surely after that, the board?
But I’ll tell you this much, if Nicholson mans up and sacks Nancy, then he should follow that with his own resignation.
I’ll leave you with this pearl of wisdom from him:
He was our number one candidate going into the process. The more we looked into it, the more we saw that he aligned with what we need and what our vision for the club is.
If what we have seen from Wilfried Nancy in the last seven fixtures is your vision for the club, then God help us.
That statement alone is enough to force Nicholson’s resignation.
He should look back on that and admit to himself he is just as much out of his depth as the manager is.
If you want to be remembered for doing something good for Celtic, Michael, pull the plug if we lose on Saturday.
Following that, admit that the CEO role at Celtic is not for you.
Step aside and allow people who are capable of doing the job come in and do the job.
End this nightmare while you still have the chance.
Key Takeaways
- Celtic fans are frustrated with the board’s poor decisions and the failed Wilfried Nancy project.
- Nancy’s management has led to disastrous performances, questioning his ability and tactics.
- Dropping key players after recent victories raised further doubts about Nancy’s decisions.
- A loss against the Ibrox side could make Nancy’s position untenable and tarnish the club’s reputation.
- The board must prioritise the club’s future and consider necessary changes after the upcoming match.
Eric, with the greatest respect I have to ask of you;
1.Are you schizophrenic ?
2.Do you suffer from multiple personality disorder ?
or
3.Are you fuckin insane ?
You have just ,quite rightly, set out the reasons why this charlatan (I mean the manager at this point) should have been sacked on the spot last night then go on to say he should be given command(ha ha) of our team selection and tactics (guffaw,guffaw)for Saturday’s game against the huns !
There should have been no need for any hesitation in giving him the bullet last night,after which Nicholson should have put the revolver in that mouth that he rarely ever opens and pulled the fuckin trigger !
If this fraud is still in situ after the game on Saturday we,the season ticket holders,are going to have to go nuclear and embark on a programme of full stadium boycotts because we cannot affect the team in a positive way even if we are there as they are incapable of playing any differently under this guys instructions.
It’s time to get real and take the gloves off and really start hitting our useless board where it hurts them the most…..In the pocket !
They might just get used to the realisation that 55,000 people aren’t going to sanction this act of self harm into another season.
Let them use their fabled waiting list to stem the flow on non renewals of season books,I doubt that will even come close to solving that looming problem.
As the great Roberto Duran once said when he had taken enough punishment,the Celtic fanbase should be emulating him by saying “No mas !!!”
Someone commented on a forum that perhaps he’ll at least stay in place for the next game, as it wouldn’t be right to potentially lose it under a new manager/caretaker and after it, he can go and someone else can come in. Other than that, the guy is a busted flush; we all know it, the press know it, rivals know it, the players know it. Do the board? I suspect they are having a meeting about who will step in. I think if Maloney was willing, then he has a great rapport with the players, particularly from the last spell with MON.
It’s clear that this is not just divisive any more but dangerous. I feel for the players (a bit). He’s mental playing 3 at the back. Okay, so how do you keep all the defenders happy, if you’re only playing 1 at a time? And who would buy these players if we sell them on, after playing that specific system? As for all the other out of position tactics he’s using, he either has a massive bet on how far he can troll the fans. Or he is utterly clueless about Scottish, British and European football. From coaching teenage girls to managing us.
But this is all on the board. Punted the manager, sold key players and replaced them with board signings that are already leaving (Inamura). And called the fans ungrateful plebs. It feels odd to consider not winning as a longer term positive but if we lose to the derby side, then surely that is the end of this mental experiment and please, hoof that permanently hungover-looking head of football operations out the door too. The mere thought of that arrogant imbecile holding the purse strings is just as worrying. Then it’ll be the turn of orville the duck, who gets paid to be ceo. HH
Firstly, this manager is not the one to take the team forward, the stubborn board need to accept their mistakes, like the Rangers board did & sort it NOW. We (Celtic Supporters) can moan about what’s happening with the team but, when you look back on history within Celtic since the days of Jock Stein, Celtic board have always been the cause of all problems on the pitch. Two 10 in a row episodes which imploded because, the Celtic board would not back the manager by building on success. Celtic have a Main Shareholder who will happily live off his dividends as long as the club are making profits every year. Supporters need to step back, reduce the money they pay into the club, like we did in the 90’s & maybe Desmond will get an offer he CANNOT refuse & the club can then hopefully grow, like the supporters crave. 💚
Nicholson is a bottler who will never make the decision to punt Nancy and Tisdale
It would show that the board’s choice of manager is a complete fuck up and I think they would rather lose the league than admit a huge mistake. They are too arrogant and incompetent. I suspect we will lose badly at the weekend to a shite Sevco side and Nancy will come out and still claim we are on the right track
He can piss off back to Soccerball USA and hopefully take Doctor Death with him.
The only solution to our current conundrum, would be to immediately appoint Peter Lawwell as manager…with a 10 year contract. He has managed to balls up everything else he has overseen at Celtic. Surely, by law of averages, he can get one thing right? Then again, maybe not.
Hail Hail.
If we lose on Saturday he surely has to go, and if he doesn’t we gave no chance of even finishing second. As someone else posted the only action left for us is boycott the home games as we can’t help the team anyway. The board must be getting desperate as they are advertising the paradise windfall on STV. A boycott should finish them off. They already have the season ticket money but match day revenue is required to keep the lights on. What company will pay sponsorship and advertising if there is nobody there to see it.
Sack Nancy today.
The guy is clueless and doesn’t deserve a shot at the huns.What if he sneaks a result,it will only be a short term fix that will come back and bite us a couple of games down the line and by then it will be to late to fix.
Get Maloney in now even if it’s a short term solution to steady the ship.Get a couple of new faces in to bolster the squad and go and win the league as the huns are shite and Hearts will bottle it.
Last roll of the dice needs to happen before Saturday.
Thanks for another very good article Eric.
Happy 2026.