“I’ve apologised because I thought the referee allowed the ball to be taken 20 yards further up the field.”
Martin O’Neill’s explanation after Hearts scored at Celtic Park says everything about David Dickinson’s latest failure. Celtic had just gone 4-0 ahead when the ball went out for a Hearts throw-in. The restart was taken much further forward, and Dickinson allowed play to continue. Hearts scored from the attack.
O’Neill’s estimate was around 20 yards. The match screenshots appear to support that distance. This was not a marginal call. Dickinson had a clear responsibility to manage the restart, yet Celtic were left to defend from a position they should never have faced.
A repeat of costly Celtic decisions
The Hearts incident is not the only major Dickinson decision to leave Celtic with serious questions.
In October 2024, he refereed Celtic’s 3-0 win at Motherwell. Daizen Maeda put the ball in the net, but the goal was ruled out for handball. The SFA’s independent Key Match Incident panel later concluded by a 4-1 majority that Stephen O’Donnell had fouled Maeda before the handball. Celtic should have been awarded a penalty.
Then, in May 2026, Dickinson was in charge when Celtic beat Hibernian 2-1 at Easter Road. A two-handed push by Josh Campbell sent Benjamin Nygren to the ground. No penalty was given and VAR did not intervene. The SFA’s KMI panel later unanimously ruled that the on-field decision was wrong, and that VAR should have recommended a review.
O’Neill was furious. He called the decisions “pretty crap” and described the push on Nygren as “a definite penalty”. That was not just a manager venting after a difficult game: the panel’s review backed him on the key penalty claim.
Dickinson must answer for it
Celtic won 7-1 against Hearts, but the scoreline does not erase the error. A referee’s job is to apply the rules consistently, especially when a restart can move a team 20 yards closer to goal.
One poor decision can happen. Repeated high-profile mistakes, including two later backed by the SFA’s own review panel, raise a larger question about Dickinson’s standard. Celtic supporters are entitled to call his performances very poor. They do not need to claim bias to demand better.
The SFA should explain how this throw-in was allowed to stand while the referee watched. Celtic should not have to rely on Martin O’Neill’s apology or television screenshots to make an obvious point: the restart was taken from the wrong place, and Dickinson failed to stop it.
While I agree that the throw in was taken from the wrong position, I’m not sure that the screenshot is of that specific incident.
The Linesman is in the picture and he isn’t in that area of the park. The Linesman is on the North Stand side and not the Main Stand side where the throw in was taken.
If we could keep that momentum going and actually get a settled continous first team then we can only get better. The problem is I don’t think MON actually knows the names of half of them. He totally lost his train of thought in the interview after the game and had to ask after going on a tangent which player he had been asked about. I genuinely believe he was correct when he said he had no idea that a goalkeeper was training with us. That’s concerning. I wonder if he’ll remember on Thursday which team played on Sunday or are we in for more changes we will see in a few days time.
And Kojak’s minion from the old Sky Sports -Crocker – erupted in glee while commentating at Hearts’ goal …like it was the winner rather than a consolation goal at 4-1 ! Positively ebullient . While in the state of the art tiny sardine like red studio used by the SS inside Celtic Park yesterday there was a distinct ‘sadness ‘ feeling from Ms Barbour and big fake Kris Boyd at Celtic battering Hearts into submission with a 7-1 hammering …going on 10 ..minimum ! Reminiscent of the final league game of last the season where Celtic clinched the title against the same lame outfit …very similar ambience ! No funnies being cracked by the big fake one yesterday ….none whatsoever !
How Dickinson yellow carded 3 Celts in 5 minutes, IMO only one was within the stick on bookable rules via a pull back, yet later on a Celtic player was pulled back, guess what? No yellow card! Double standards in full view.
Dickinson also gave hearts a soft free kick just outside the box at 2-0, trying to get them back in the game.
He reffed several of the rangers games in November and December last year and got them back in the title race with several points winning dodgy decisions.
He’s probably the worst in the spl as far as Celtic are concerned.
This yin is worth a fu**in watchin for sure !