27.10.2012 Glasgow, Scotland.Brother Walfrid Statue in action during the Scottish Premier League game between Celtic and Kilmarmock from Celtic Park.
Having spent considerable time digesting Celtic Supporters Limited’s voting intentions, I’m beginning to wonder whether there is considerably more to its strategy than meets the eye.
I still can’t be sure what they are though!
David Low’s appearance on Celtic World Order yesterday certainly provided some interesting insights into the organisation’s potential long-term ambitions.
However, too many questions remain unanswered.
I also remain extremely disappointed by the language Low chose to use when discussing sections of the Celtic support.
What Is CSL’s Long Term Strategy?
One particularly interesting aspect of Low’s interview concerned the possibility of CSL eventually acquiring Dermot Desmond’s shareholding.
Low presented this as a hypothetical scenario rather than something remotely imminent.
Nevertheless, it got me thinking.
Could the possibility of eventually doing business with Desmond explain CSL’s reluctance to antagonise him?
Within its published voting intentions, CSL specifically references avoiding a “headline vote against” Desmond.
Why does that headline matter?
Furthermore, Low suggested that CSL’s actions at the AGM could have a bearing on its ongoing initiative involving the Takeover Panel.
I’d love to understand precisely what an outright vote against Celtic’s directors might jeopardise.
Then there’s the conditional twelve-month mandate CSL proposes granting several directors.
Have those directors actually agreed to the conditions?
Should they fail to deliver, what additional leverage does CSL anticipate possessing this time next year?
These are legitimate questions that deserve comprehensive answers.
Those answers would encourage considerably more Celtic supporters to buy into the strategy.
David Low’s Language Remains Unacceptable
Unfortunately, the manner in which Low addressed some of the criticism directed towards CSL did little to encourage that buy-in.
When discussing those who might interpret CSL’s successful resolution concerning untraced shares as evidence of a close relationship with Celtic’s board, Low referred to “dafties” before adding that “only an imbecile would think that.”
Later, whilst defending CSL’s willingness to make difficult decisions, he described people as “barking at the moon.”
Really?
That’s the sort of language I would associate with those occupying the Celtic boardroom when discussing dissenting supporters behind closed doors.
Surely we should expect considerably better from somebody involved in an organisation seeking to empower those supporters?
Nobody should be surprised that CSL’s voting recommendations generated such a reaction.
After all, the organisation had previously been extremely critical of Celtic’s corporate governance.
Recommending the re-election of five directors was always going to require some explaining.
People Buy From People
There may well be elements of CSL’s strategy that, once explained fully, I find myself buying into.
I’m certainly open to that possibility.
However, there’s a fundamental principle that applies whether you’re running a business, standing for election or attempting to build a supporter ownership movement.
People buy from people.
CSL needs the trust, confidence and financial backing of Celtic supporters to realise its ambitions.
Consequently, those representing the organisation should choose their words carefully when addressing the very people whose support they require.
Dismissing legitimate concerns with ridicule doesn’t sell your strategy.
It undermines it.
Celtic’s current custodians have demonstrated precisely what happens when those seeking the financial commitment of supporters lose sight of the importance of their relationship with them.
Surely CSL should be learning from those mistakes rather than repeating them?
You might possess the most intelligent strategy in the room, but you still need to convince the people in that room.
Without them, there is no movement.
People buy from people.
Those at Celtic Supporters Limited would do well to remember that.