15th December 2024; Hampden Park, Glasgow, Scotland; Premier Sports Cup Football Final, Celtic versus Rangers;
Alex Valle was on loan at Celtic in 2024, and there was no doubt we could see a good player emerging every time he pulled on the jersey.
He is now plying his trade at Como, and he is flourishing.
According to the Herald, he is an established member of a team making waves in the Champions League, and he has earned a regular place in the Spain Under-21 set-up.
Last time I looked, he also played the full 90 minutes and provided an assist in a 9-1 demolition of Lens.
9-1.
In the Champions League.
Not bad for a left-back we couldn’t hold on to.
Valle gives Brendan Rodgers the credit for broadening his footballing education
Speaking to MARCA, Valle reflected on how different the demands were when he came to Scottish football.
Here is what he said, as reported by the Herald:
“I worked hard because it’s a different league. Very tough, very physical. Even though the technical level isn’t high, it’s hard to win.”
Now, I’m not going to get on my high horse about that one.
He’s right.
The Scottish Premiership isn’t a league where you get a game on a plate, and anybody who has watched Celtic grind out a result on a wet Tuesday in a ground with a pitch like a ploughed field will tell you the same.
It’s the technical bit that stings, but who are we to argue when we’ve all seen it with our own eyes?
What matters is what came next.
“Brendan Rodgers’ style of play caught my attention. I ended up learning some midfield concepts.”
Think about that for a second.
A left-back, a young one, walks into Celtic Park and walks out with midfield concepts he can take with him to Italy.
That’s what a proper manager does with a young player.
And that’s what makes the next part so frustrating.
Valle made 19 appearances and always acquitted himself well, but there was never an option to buy
I know I’m sounding like a broken record, but this is the same old story.
Valle came in on loan from Barcelona and made 19 appearances for the club.
In all of them, he acquitted himself well.
But there was never an option to buy in his loan, which, funnily enough, generally seems to be the case when quality players arrive at Celtic on loan.
Apparently, we’re just meant to enjoy them while they’re here.
Then they move on.
In Valle’s case, he moved on to Como in 2025, and we got another loanee in to replace him in the form of Jeffrey Schlupp.
Como, meanwhile, turned his loan into a permanent move and paid Barcelona in the region of €6m for him.
Six million euros.
For a player who had spent the first half of that season at Celtic Park.
I’m not saying Celtic should have spent that money, but I am saying it would have been nice to at least be in the room when the conversation was being had.
Then again, he was Barcelona’s player, not ours, and I’m not daft enough to think it was ever just a matter of asking nicely.
But that’s the point.
Celtic are happy to borrow quality, but the board never seem to want to keep it
Because this is the model.
Take the loan, use the player, hand him back, and call it a good window as long as the books balance.
Is that fair every single time?
Maybe not.
But it’s exactly what it looks like from where the support sits.
As I discussed in my article on loans, flops and projects, we never seem to hold on to the ones who did well on loan for us.
And the ones we do hold on to?
Well, I think we all know how that story goes.
Valle has gone from strength to strength, and he doesn’t forget where it started
You can say what you like about the way Celtic go about their business, but Valle’s reaction tells you a lot about the man.
He didn’t need to say a word about Brendan Rodgers.
He’s playing in the Champions League for one of the most exciting emerging sides in Europe, and he’s being coached by Cesc FÃ bregas, who he describes as hugely ambitious with a winning mentality, a man who fears ‘nothing and no one’.
He could easily have left Celtic in the rear-view mirror and not looked back.
Instead, he took the time to give credit to the manager who, in his words, helped him learn.
It’s a lesson in class, and it’s a lesson that some of our own players could do with learning.
Still, it’s hard not to wonder.
What if there had been an option to buy?
What if the club had looked at a young player who was clearly going somewhere and thought, ‘let’s make sure he stays here’?
Would he be flourishing at Celtic Park right now, or would he be another one that didn’t kick on under this board?
Your guess is as good as mine…
But I know which way I’d be betting.
At least Valle got something out of his time at Celtic.
The club certainly didn’t.
End of.
Key Takeaways
- Alex Valle impressed during his loan at Celtic, showcasing his potential as a quality player.
- Now at Como, Valle has thrived, earning recognition in the Champions League and Spain Under-21s.
- Celtic missed the chance to secure Valle permanently despite his strong performances.
- The club often borrows talent but rarely keeps quality players like Valle.
- Valle acknowledges Brendan Rodgers for enhancing his footballing education, highlighting the missed opportunity for Celtic.
Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.