Yesterday, I wrote an article on Dermot Desmond’s control and influence over Celtic.
While doing my research on that particular article, I came across an interview between Desmond and Joe Sullivan on the official Celtic website back in 2014.
I took some excerpts from it in yesterday’s article, but if I’m being honest, it warrants closer scrutiny.
Because ultimately, everything contained within it, and committed to by Desmond himself, has never really happened.
Aside from the points I looked at yesterday, there were a few more that stood out to me.
The first one that raised my eyebrow was the the answer to this question:
Was it his (Fergus McCann’s) business plan and Share Issue that you found attractive?
The plan was really to create a solid financial platform for Celtic and really to spread the ownership among the fans and among other people who were genuinely interested in the welfare of Celtic. We would develop the club on the basis of having a very good infrastructure – good stadium, good training grounds and a good management structure.
The answer itself is admirable.
In theory, it’s exactly what we want to see at Celtic today.
The ownership spread amongst the fans and amongst other people who were genuinely interested in the welfare of Celtic.
Therein lies three critical words.
Welfare of Celtic...
The man who stated that the welfare of Celtic was what mattered to him certainly doesn’t seem to be keeping up his part of the bargain when it comes to that, does he?
It seems that the welfare of the bank balance is all that has ever mattered.
Evidenced by the fact that everything else around it seems to be crumbling.
Desmond stated that very good infrastructure was key to the welfare of Celtic.
12 years later, that certainly isn’t the case when it comes to Celtic Park.
I can’t really argue with the training grounds, because to be fair, those facilities are pretty good.
But what good are excellent training facilities if they’re not being used by a top class squad?
Then Desmond states that the club would be developed on the basis of a good management structure
Today at Celtic, we have a manager who is closing in on his 75th birthday, no technical director, and no head of scouting
Good management structure?
I beg to differ.
Maybe through the prism of Dermot Desmond in 2026, but certainly not through the prism of the modern game.
So why did Dermot Desmond state that this was the plan?
Maybe it was Fergus McCann’s plan, and he’s taking some credit for it, but it certainly does not seem to be the plan in 2026.
It is clear now that what were Fergus McCann’s long term plans for Celtic, and what are Dermot Desmond’s long term plans are completely at odds with each other.
Desmond has made it clear that he has no long term strategy for Celtic
He has never had one.
The fact that the board asked shareholders to vote against the proposal to publish a long term strategy at the upcoming AGM tells us this much.
This next question was one I also found the answer to very interesting:
Was it his (Fergus McCann’s) business plan and Share Issue that you found attractive
I think if you get criticism from the media it’s really a vote of confidence in what you’re doing so I think Fergus McCann took it like that. The media find it very easy to criticise pragmatic businessmen, especially in football, and they also criticise foolish businessmen who invest in football, so I think I’d like to be on the side of the pragmatic businessperson and I think Fergus was that type of person.
What’s interesting about this segment, is that Desmond has never really faced criticism from the media.
Until now, that is.
But that has only happened because Celtic fan media has gone in hard and been relentless in exposing the shambolic way the club is being run over the last couple of years.
Any criticism of Desmond from here on out certainly isn’t going to be a vote of confidence.
It hasn’t been in fan media, and since the mainstream media are now following fan media’s lead on this, you can be sure there will be no mercy from here on out.
Desmond talks about pragmatism, even though he himself is the furthest thing from pragmatic when it comes to Celtic.
Being pragmatic means dealing with problems, decisions, or situations in a practical, sensible and realistic way based on actual conditions.
There are a lot of problems at Celtic at the moment that aren’t being dealt with.
All decisions at Celtic are being made by one individual, which is to the detriment of the club
Because one person cannot make all the decisions for an institute the size of Celtic.
It’s not possible.
It is neither practical, nor sensible.
The actual conditions at Celtic, as outlined by Charlie Methven, are shambolic.
Pragmatism and Dermot Desmond are a million miles apart right now.
Desmond talks a good game in an interview situation, but he certainly does not deliver on very much of what he says, or in this case, said.
The final question I’m going to discuss is the one I found the most interesting.
It tells us why the bank balance, first and foremost, is all that matters at Celtic:
How do you think Celtic stand as a business in the market just now and how do you think it’s evolved over the last 20 years?
If you look at the financial matrix between Celtic and other clubs in the UK, whether you are talking about Premiership clubs or Championship clubs, is that our profit and loss performance, our balance sheet performance and our performance on the field exceeds that of other clubs. And we’re shackled by the lack of revenues that we have from TV and comparable income that Premiership and Championship clubs get.
Two things stand out here.
Firstly, the profit and loss and balance sheet performance was always good, up until now that is.
Desmond has the fans to thank for that.
Which he never will.
Secondly, Desmond then states that our performance on the field exceeds that of other clubs.
Who is he referring to when he says ‘other clubs’?
Because back in 2014, our biggest rivals were Aberdeen.
The Ibrox side would be languishing in the lower leagues for another two years after that
Then Desmond as much as admits that Celtic are shackled by the TV revenues the club gets in comparison to Championship and EPL clubs.
So, if we’re shackled by those revenues, why would we not strive to secure the revenues that come with Champions League qualification?
Instead of always gambling on this?
The reality is that the entirety of that interview, today, just looks like complete bullshit.
Desmond sold the fans a vision of the future in 2014, and very little of that vision has been delivered.
12 years later and Celtic has regressed into a state of total chaos.
Yet nobody within the club is willing to take on the chaos engine itself, Dermot Desmond
Celtic will continue to wither and wilt under his singular control.
Meanwhile, the fans are attempting to come together to challenge this singular authority, but the board’s only response to this is to try and sow division amongst the various fan groups.
All of this comes from one man.
Which leaves us with a couple of critical questions…
Why is Desmond so hell bent on fiddling while Rome burns?
And what is it that he has against the people who are the lifeblood of Celtic?
Some day, we might have the answers to those questions, but for now we must continue to apply pressure to him and his crumbling regime.
Desmond’s 2014 interview shows us that he is a liar and a charlatan.
He and his regime cannot be trusted.
They do not, and have not ever, had the best interests of Celtic at heart.
The Celtic fans do.
Which is why we must all come together to enact change at Celtic.
Because the ‘welfare of Celtic’ is now under an existential threat.
And the very man who once claimed he was only interested in the ‘welfare of Celtic’, is now its biggest threat.
The time for asking why he has become Celtic’s biggest threat is long past.
The time for removing that threat is now at hand.
The rebels won in 1994, it’s time they won again…
Key Takeaways
- Dermot Desmond’s claims about prioritising Celtic’s welfare contradict the current reality of the club’s management and infrastructure.
- Over 12 years, Desmond has failed to deliver on promises made in a 2014 interview, resulting in Celtic’s decline.
- The club lacks a clear long-term strategy, with all decisions being made by Desmond, which harms Celtic’s future.
- Fan media is now holding Desmond accountable, leading to increased criticism from both fans and mainstream media.
- The time has come for fans to unite and challenge Desmond’s control, as his leadership poses an existential threat to Celtic.
Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.