Kris Boyd’s Celtic crisis verdict deserves a closer look. In comments reported by GlasgowWorld on 12 November, the former Ibrox striker contrasted our struggles with the improving fortunes of his old club.
Fair enough. Celtic have given us plenty to criticise. However, there is an awkward detail running through this assessment: the supposedly troubled champions remain ahead of the team gathering all that momentum.
Four points ahead, with the Ibrox club holding a game in hand. That qualification matters. So does the fact that they still have to win it.
The Celtic crisis verdict needs some perspective
In GlasgowWorld’s report of his comments, Boyd described the reaction to Falkirk as though Celtic had pressed the “crisis button”.
I would hardly describe that defeat as acceptable. Nor would I pretend that scraping past Kilmarnock suddenly answered every question about Martin O’Neill’s team.
Our assessment of Celtic’s attacking problems makes that clear. Supporters can see the issues without needing Boyd to point towards them.
Nevertheless, poor performances and competitive resilience can exist together. A team can struggle for fluency and still show something valuable when it finds a winning goal.
That part deserves proper consideration too.
If Celtic’s narrow victories merely delay another crisis, what would count as evidence that the players are responding?
Boyd’s own concession matters
To his credit, Boyd did acknowledge the response after Falkirk. As the same report records, he said:
“But they found a way to win against Besiktas and again at the weekend.”
Exactly.
That does not erase the weaknesses. It does, however, complicate the picture of a team permanently waiting to fall apart.
Our report on the Beşiktaş comeback explained why that response mattered. Celtic recovered from going behind, then answered another setback when the visitors equalised late on.
There was football substance in that victory: effective changes, decisive finishing and players accepting responsibility.
Against Kilmarnock, the performance offered less encouragement. Yet the points still counted. Nobody awards a smaller prize for winning while supporters are chewing their fingernails.
The concern is whether Celtic can sustain those results without improving. That is a serious football question. Reaching for crisis language adds little unless we also examine what the wins tell us.
The chasing team still has work to do
The Ibrox club’s unbeaten run deserves recognition. Boyd has grounds to believe his former side can challenge, and Celtic would be foolish to dismiss that threat.
But an improving challenger has not already completed the job.
A game in hand offers an opportunity to reduce the gap. It does not reduce it automatically. Likewise, looking more convincing over a recent run does not settle what happens over the rest of the season.
That is why I find the contrast in Boyd’s assessment more interesting than the criticism itself.
Celtic’s difficulties become a warning about what might happen next. The chasing club’s improvement becomes a reason to anticipate something better. Both involve a forecast.
I want Celtic to play better, recruit better and give us fewer reasons to worry. Being ahead cannot become an excuse for accepting obvious shortcomings.
However, those shortcomings do not cancel the points already earned.
Boyd can make his case for the challengers. Until they overtake Celtic, though, his resurgent former club remain exactly that.
The challengers.
Key takeaways
- Boyd’s comments were reported on 12 November, rather than made today.
- Celtic lead by four points, with the Ibrox club holding a game in hand.
- Celtic’s performances need improvement, but their response after Falkirk deserves credit.