Celtic shareholders have every right to ask questions about the people running their football club. They should also have every right to expect clear, meaningful answers.
Yet an arrangement dating back to 2005 has now prompted a formal legal enquiry.
And for me, that raises a question every bit as important as the original agreement.
Why should Celtic shareholders need solicitors to establish the facts?
According to Celtic Supporters Limited, the organisation instructed Macdonald Henderson solicitors to write to Celtic plc on 16 November.
Their questions concern arrangements connected to Dermot Desmond’s increased shareholding during the club’s £15 million share issue in 2005.
Twenty-one years later, shareholders want clarity about the obligations associated with that transaction.
Surely that is not an unreasonable request?
Celtic shareholders have a legitimate question
Under Rule 9 of the Takeover Code, a shareholder crossing the relevant 30% voting-rights threshold would normally be required to make an offer to other shareholders.
However, a waiver was approved in connection with the 2005 transaction, with independent shareholders giving their consent.
Celtic Supporters Limited now wants to establish whether an undertaking understood to have been given by Desmond and/or Line Nominees Limited remains in force.
It also wants to know whether that undertaking has changed, what protections it provides minority shareholders and how any continuing obligations are monitored.
Importantly, the organisation has not accused anybody of wrongdoing.
Nor has any breach been established.
Nevertheless, the questions deserve answers.
Why has Celtic’s board allowed uncertainty to continue?
Here is what I find particularly troubling.
Celtic are a publicly listed company, with responsibilities extending beyond the interests of any individual shareholder.
Dermot Desmond may exercise considerable influence, but Celtic do not belong exclusively to him.
Every shareholder has a legitimate interest in understanding the company’s governance arrangements.
Yet supporters are now examining decisions made more than two decades ago to establish precisely what commitments were made.
That is an extraordinary position.
The original arrangements may prove entirely proper. Indeed, there may be a straightforward explanation for every question raised.
But if that is the case, why not provide it?
Of course, some historical agreements may contain confidential information. Legal restrictions must be respected.
However, confidentiality should not become an excuse for avoiding every reasonable question.
There is an important difference between protecting confidential information and failing to explain the principles governing a publicly listed company.
Celtic’s AGM is now about more than football
The timing could hardly be more significant.
Celtic’s official AGM notice confirms that shareholders will gather on 1 December.
That meeting will take place against a backdrop of considerable supporter frustration over the direction of the club.
Meanwhile, Celtic Supporters Limited has requested a response within 14 days of its solicitors’ letter.
This presents the board with an opportunity.
Explain what can be disclosed. Clarify whether the undertaking remains relevant. Identify any continuing responsibilities.
And where information cannot legally be released, explain why.
That would demonstrate a genuine commitment to accountability.
Celtic cannot demand trust while questions remain
There is a tendency in football to treat questions about powerful individuals as personal attacks.
They are not.
Asking whether an undertaking remains legally effective is not an allegation of misconduct.
Requesting information about shareholder protections is not an attempt to undermine the football club.
And expecting directors to explain governance arrangements is certainly not unreasonable.
Quite the opposite.
These are precisely the questions responsible shareholders should be asking.
For too long, Celtic’s wider governance debate has revolved around personalities, influence and competing claims about who makes the important decisions.
Perhaps this enquiry will provide some much-needed clarity.
I hope it does.
Because the central issue is not whether Dermot Desmond has done something wrong. No evidence presented here establishes that.
The issue is whether Celtic’s board can provide shareholders with the transparency they deserve.
Twenty-one years after the original transaction, that should not be an impossible task.
Celtic’s shareholders are asking for answers, not favours.
And the distinction should matter to everyone inside that boardroom.
Key takeaways
- Celtic Supporters Limited has instructed solicitors to seek clarification about a 2005 shareholding arrangement.
- The questions concern an undertaking understood to be associated with Dermot Desmond and/or Line Nominees Limited.
- The organisation has not alleged wrongdoing, and no breach has been established.
- Celtic’s AGM takes place on 1 December, with shareholders seeking greater accountability.
- The wider question is whether Celtic’s board can provide clarity without shareholders having to pursue formal legal enquiries.
Further reading
Celtic’s Ross Desmond role raises boardroom questions
Celtic AGM: Shareholders seek answers on December 1