AI-generated illustration of if you'd told me at the start of the season that one of the loudest voices against the Celtic board would be broadcasting.
If you’d told me at the start of the season that one of the loudest voices against the Celtic board would be broadcasting from Connecticut, I’d have laughed at you.
But here we are.
Since we were knocked out of the Champions League, Ian Joy has become a new and independent voice when it comes to the trials and tribulations of our club.
And he hasn’t held back.
His rants about Celtic on the CBS Sports Golazo Network have gone viral on social media this season.
Not many people in Scotland knew who he was before this season.
They do now.
Joy has become an unexpected voice for Celtic on a much broader platform than anyone here could give him.
Think about that for a second.
A lad from Bo’ness is sitting in a studio in the United States, on what CBS call the number one channel for the sport in America, telling a massive audience exactly what is wrong with Celtic.
And there’s nobody at Celtic Park who can do a thing about it.
He doesn’t need access.
Nor does he need a press pass.
He doesn’t even need to keep anyone in the boardroom sweet so that he gets his next exclusive.
In fact, he’s in a place where he simply can’t be discouraged from open discourse about the state of things at Celtic at the moment.
Compare that to how things work over here.
We all know what happens to journalists in Scotland who ask the wrong questions of the Celtic board.
The phone stops ringing.
The invites stop coming.
Joy doesn’t have that problem.
What are they going to do, ban him from a press conference he was never going to attend?
It seems that his love for Celtic didn’t start in Bo’ness – it started in Hamburg.
Now, here’s the part I didn’t know.
Joy wasn’t a Celtic fan growing up.
He told the Herald that his local clubs were Falkirk and Livingston, and that’s all he cared about as a boy.
It was at St. Pauli where it all changed for him.
Here’s what he had to say:
“I fell in love with Celtic when I was a player at St. Pauli in Germany during the 2000s.
I really came to understand their supporter culture and what they stood for as a club during that time.
There would always be Celtic supporters at St Pauli home matches and every month hundreds of their fans would travel out for one game.”
Apparently, our supporters used to bring him cans of Irn Bru and Scotch pies.
Of course they did.
That’s the Celtic support all over.
And anyone who knows anything about the bond between the two clubs will understand exactly how that happened.
Joy said himself that he thinks St. Pauli are very similar to Celtic.
A club about far more than football.
A club built for the people, and not the balance sheet.
You can see why he fell for us.
You can also see why he’s so angry about what we’ve become.
As the voices of dissent grow louder against the current regime, Joy very suddenly became one of them.
Dermot Desmond and his executive team have come under fire from the support once again this season.
Protests, boycotts, the lot.
The mainstream media like to paint those of us who are fed up as some sort of militant faction.
We’re not.
We just want our club back.
And it turns out a former left-back on American TV wants the same thing.
Who’d have thought it?
But the thing that struck me most from his interview is that his outbursts aren’t just about frustration with how Celtic are run.
They’re fuelled as much by a desire to see football flourish in his homeland.
Joy wants Scottish football to have a team that can compete in Europe again.
And he knows that team should be Celtic.
“Scottish football needs a Scottish team to have success on the European stage.
It is Champions League or bust for Celtic as far as I’m concerned now.
To be beaten by a team with the limited quality of LASK is unacceptable for a club of their size.”
LASK.
LASK!
Let that sink in.
Then again, it’s not as if he’s blind to the other side of the argument.
He’s the first to admit that Celtic are run incredibly well as a business, and that nobody can fault the board for £60m, £70m, £80m sitting in the bank.
Fair enough.
But he also reminded them that they’re in the entertainment business.
And then he said this:
“Sorry, but Celtic Football Club is built on fear. They have a fear of failure.”
I’ve been saying the same thing for years.
Is he wrong?
Of course he isn’t.
A club that’s happy to drop into the Europa League because the books will still balance is a club with no ambition.
That’s the model.
That’s always been the model under the absent meddling golfer.
Balance the books, bank the profit, and treat Europe as a BONUS.
Joy knows a thing or two about how clubs are run, too.
He completed his UEFA Certificate in Football Management in August, and he’s sat in a seminar at UEFA HQ listening to the CEO of PSV Eindhoven explain how a single goal was worth €20m to his club.
So when he says that some clubs put finances ahead of the experience of their own supporters, and that he puts Celtic into that category, it’s not some pundit shooting from the hip.
He’s seen how it’s done properly.
He’s also seen 250 Celtic fans packed into a bar in New York to watch a game.
He knows how big this club is.
So why don’t the people running it act like it?
Your guess is as good as mine.
As the season goes on, it will be interesting to keep up with Joy’s Celtic opinions now that he’s emerged as a relatively new critic of the Desmond regime.
Because the board can freeze out the press in Scotland all they like.
They can’t freeze out CBS.
Keep watching this space…
Key Takeaways
- Ian Joy, broadcasting from the US, has become a vocal critic of Celtic, attracting attention with his rants on CBS Sports Golazo Network.
- Joy’s independent voice contrasts with the limited questioning faced by Scottish journalists of the Celtic board.
- He wasn’t a Celtic fan growing up but developed a passion for the club after experiencing its community spirit in Hamburg.
- As fans protest against Celtic’s management, Joy expresses a desire for the club to return to its competitive roots in European football.
- He believes that prioritising finances over fan experience reflects a lack of ambition from those running Celtic.
Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.