Celtic’s Colby Donovan has arguably been the shining light of a difficult season. However, with Alistair Johnston approaching a return, Martin O’Neill faces an interesting selection dilemma.
And the situation becomes even more intriguing when you examine just how close Johnston came to leaving Celtic for Everton.
Because this isn’t simply about choosing between two right-backs.
It’s about Celtic preparing for the future while rewarding a youngster who has earned his opportunity.
Celtic’s Colby Donovan dilemma deserves serious thought
First, let’s give Alistair Johnston the credit he deserves.
The Canadian has been an outstanding signing for Celtic. His defensive intelligence, aggression, consistency and commitment have made him one of the club’s most reliable performers.
In my opinion, a fully fit Johnston remains the more accomplished player.
There should be absolutely no argument about his quality.
However, his recent injury record is becoming a genuine concern.
And there is another important factor.
Everton came remarkably close to signing Johnston
During the summer, Everton made a serious attempt to bring Johnston to the Premier League.
As Canadian Soccer Daily reported, Martin O’Neill confirmed that David Moyes had personally contacted him about the defender.
Reports suggested Everton were offering approximately £12 million, potentially rising to £15 million with add-ons.
However, Celtic’s valuation remained a stumbling block.
Then Johnston suffered another injury.
O’Neill subsequently indicated the Canadian would not recover before the transfer deadline.
Consequently, a move that had looked a genuine possibility never materialised.
More recently, Football Insider reported that Celtic could entertain a £15 million offer in January.
However, Everton’s concerns about Johnston’s fitness could prevent another approach.
That distinction matters. A January departure remains possible, but it is far from guaranteed.
Celtic have discovered something special in Donovan
Meanwhile, Donovan has taken his opportunity brilliantly.
The 20-year-old has started 18 of Celtic’s previous 19 matches and recently signed a contract running until 2031.
Martin O’Neill even described him as exceptional in Celtic’s official contract announcement.
For me, Donovan has been one of the few genuine positives this season.
His energy, attitude and willingness to take responsibility have been refreshing.
Furthermore, his development demonstrates exactly what Celtic can achieve when academy graduates receive meaningful opportunities.
We raised similar concerns in our recent examination of the Celtic academy pathway.
Why Celtic should keep faith with Donovan
Johnston deserves enormous respect.
But Celtic must consider the bigger picture.
His injury problems have restricted his availability, while Premier League interest suggests his long-term future may lie elsewhere.
Even if Johnston stays in January, another approach could arrive further down the line.
So why interrupt Donovan’s development now?
I would keep Donovan in the team while he continues performing.
Let Johnston recover properly. Let him compete for his position. And let Donovan continue building the experience that could make him Celtic’s first-choice right-back for years.
This isn’t about disrespecting an excellent senior player.
It’s about recognising an emerging one.
Celtic may already have Johnston’s eventual replacement. The last thing they should do is halt his progress.
Key takeaways
- Alistair Johnston remains an outstanding Celtic player and arguably the more accomplished right-back.
- Everton held serious discussions over a summer transfer, but no agreement was reached.
- Johnston’s recurring injuries have complicated his future and any potential January move.
- Colby Donovan has started 18 of Celtic’s previous 19 matches.
- Celtic should continue rewarding Donovan’s performances while Johnston returns to fitness.
Further reading
Celtic academy pathway – why homegrown youngsters deserve their chance