1st November 2026; Falkirk Stadium, Falkirk, Scotland; Scottish Premiership Football, Falkirk versus Celtic; Kasper Hogh of Celtic
Aiden McGeady and Ryan Stevenson felt that Kasper Høgh was probably raging after being left on the bench after Celtic’s 4-1 win over St. Mirren at Paradise yesterday.
And you know what?
They’re probably right.
Martin O’Neill’s man management has to come under scrutiny here, and I’ll tell you why.
Kasper Høgh is an investment that cost Celtic £11 million, whether he turns out to be a good investment or a bad investment remains to be seen.
Shim Mheuka is not an investment, and thus far, he has delivered the square root of f*** all when it comes to goals at Celtic.
Kasper Høgh has 3, Mheuka has none.
Granted he hasn’t scored since August, but his pedigree, and his ability to deal with adversity, will most likely change all of that.
But in order to be able to score goals, especially when you need them badly, you need to be given the opportunity when the chances of that happening are at their optimum.
4-1 up against St. Mirren yesterday was an optimum opportunity.
Martin O’Neill instead chose to go with the man who has yet to deliver anything for Celtic.
Shim Mheuka will most likely return to Chelsea in the January window, due to the fact he has delivered little to nothing for Celtic
Yes, he has shown flashes of what he can do, but it hasn’t amounted to anything.
But unless that changes radically between now and January, Stamford Bridge is his most likely destination.
Which begs the question, why was Høgh left on the bench yesterday?
What sense does it make?
Surely as a football manager, you want your prime asset to start scoring goals?
Why would you not give him that opportunity when the conditions were perfect for it?
If Shim Mheuka goes in January, Kasper Høgh will still be at the club.
Yet Martin O’Neill chose to send a negative message like this to a Celtic player who is low on confidence yesterday
He wasn’t giving Høgh game time, despite the fact the conditions were perfect for him to get that elusive goal.
What kind of message does that send to a player?
Well, as reported in the Record, former Hearts player Ryan Stevenson while commentating on BBC Sportsound, thought he would be raging:
You would be raging. You don’t really have a leg to stand on because of how he is playing, but I think you have to get him on there.
I think when it goes to four you would be looking at the manager thinking ‘come on, I’m ready to go’. You would be running past his eye line so he is at least thinking about getting you on, then he chooses to bring on someone else…
Aiden McGeady, who was also on Sportsound, hit the nail on the head with this comment:
You are bringing on a Chelsea loan player, so you are effectively developing another club’s talent.
Which is why yesterday’s decision baffles me all the more.
It doesn’t make sense from that perspective.
But there were other decisions yesterday that didn’t make much sense.
Like taking off the man of the match in the 60th minute, which changed the momentum of the tie completely.
Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain put in his 3rd man of the match performance this season
On top of that, he scored the opening goal of the game.
He was pinging balls around for fun in midfield, and when Callum McGregor once again went for attention to his bloody nose in the 60th minute, O’Neill should have made the decision to take him off and allow Oxlade-Chamberlain to remain on.
Instead, he took off the Ox, and all forward momentum came to a halt.
Yes, Joel van den Berg put himself about a bit, but he certainly didn’t have the impact Oxlade-Chamberlain had.
His years of experience really shone through yesterday.
How Martin O’Neill is not taking advantage of that on a continuous basis is beyond me.
Finally, the fact that Haissem Hassan didn’t make the bench again is a cause for concern
Good managers don’t just write off players who cost the kind of money he did.
They manage them.
Consigning him to oblivion certainly isn’t the answer.
£20 million worth of signings didn’t even make it onto the field of play yesterday.
That’s either down to bad management, or down to them being bad signings.
The jury is still out when it comes to Hassan, but Høgh’s reputation precedes him.
The decision not to play him yesterday was bad management, if you ask me.
It remains to be seen whether that will have a long term effect or not.
Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.