Right, before I get into this article, I’m not saying that Dermot Desmond performed a hostile takeover at Celtic.
Because a hostile takeover is carried out when a potential investor seeks to gain control of a target company against the wishes of the target’s management and board of directors.
To do this, the acquirer typically bypasses leadership and appeals directly to shareholders to buy a controlling stake (usually more than 50% of voting shares) or replace the board.
That’s a hostile takeover.
So, if a hostile takeover was carried out at a company, and the acquirer buys 50%+ of the shareholding, they can then do what they want with the company.
Typically, this is known as the 50% plus one share rule.
Once the acquirer goes over that 50%, they can control the company.
It is effectively theirs.
What you clearly cannot do, is control a company with a 34.9% shareholding.
A 34.9% shareholder has no automatic legal right to be involved in the day to day operations of a UK based company.
Celtic, as we know, is a UK based company
Effectively, the principal shareholder cannot be involved in the ‘operational control’ of the company.
Under UK company law, ownership and management are legally separate, meaning day-to-day business operations belong exclusively to the board of directors and executive management, not the shareholders.
Legally seperate.
A 34.9% shareholder – or even a 51% shareholder – cannot simply tell the board of directors what to do.
Under UK company law, the board of directors holds independent legal authority to manage the company.
Directors are legally required to exercise their own independent judgment rather than taking orders from any single shareholder.
Clearly Michael Nicholson, Chris McKay, and Brian Wilson et al are incapable of this at Celtic
They take their lead from somebody they shouldn’t be taking their lead from.
A 34.9% shareholder cannot tell the board who to hire or fire in the business.
Staffing decisions – including hiring and firing executives, managers, and staff – belong strictly to the board of directors and executive management.
Strictly to the board of directors.
The board and CEO hold exclusive operational power to recruit, manage, and dismiss employees.
They do not, and should not, need to defer to anyone else on these decisions.
A shareholder cannot issue hiring or firing instructions to staff or directors, as directors must exercise independent judgment rather than take orders from individual shareholders.
Independent judgement.
Is it starting to make sense now?
Dermot Desmond has ridden roughshod over the rules when it comes to his influence over Celtic.
He has effectively performed his own ‘hostile takeover’ at Celtic, illegally
He allows the current manager to refer to him as ‘the owner’.
Because Desmond has led so many people down through the years to believe that he is the de facto owner of Celtic, most people just take it to be fact.
Nobody has questioned it.
Until now, that is.
A 34.9% shareholder has no automatic legal right to issue statements through official club channels or speak on behalf of the club either.
Under UK company law, a shareholder is not an officer or agent of the company.
This mean that authority over official communications, brand channels, and public representations rests strictly with the board of directors and authorised executives.
The club’s website, social media accounts, press lists, and email channels are company assets managed by the board and media team.
If a shareholder issues a statement purporting to speak for the club without board authorisation, they risk legal liability for misrepresentation, breach of any shareholders’ agreement, or regulatory breaches
Now, clearly the current board at Celtic is complicit in allowing Desmond to behave the way he does.
This cuts both ways.
Because it’s clear none of them have the guts to put him in his place
Which they are perfectly within their rights to do.
Now, as we’ve discussed many times on the Trinity Tims podcast, none of the current board members want to give up their cushy numbers.
But it that seems they somehow think that Dermot Desmond has the right to fire them.
He does not.
The reality is that a certain kind of culture has become embedded in Celtic over the last 20 years.
The culture of Dermot Desmond.
Which nobody has ever questioned.
Recently there has been rumours of boardroom dissent.
Stories that certain individuals are not happy with the way things are run at Celtic
With all of the exposure of Desmond that has been happening of late, maybe this has emboldened some of them.
The problem is that it’s too late for most of them now.
They are complicit in this shitshow.
They have allowed it to happen on their watch.
If the walls start to close in on Desmond, then they must close in on them too.
They have failed to carry of their fiduciary duty when it comes to Celtic.
Effectively, they have acted in concert with Desmond, and given him free reign to do what he likes at Celtic.
Which brings me to my final point in this article.
The rumour that Ross Desmond is going to be appointed as club Chairman at the upcoming AGM
Let’s make one thing clear about Ross Desmond.
He does not hold an official position, executive title, or seat on the board of directors at Celtic FC.
Instead, he acts as an authorised representative for his father.
A 34.9% shareholder cannot force the appointment of his son as chairman on his own.
Under UK company law, appointing a director and selecting the chairman require either a board vote or a majority shareholder vote (over 50%), unless a specific private contract gives that shareholder direct appointment rights.
Now, we know the board could strongarmed into voting Desmond into this position.
But the question remains, should the majority shareholding be given a say in this?
And is there a specific private contract that gives Desmond direct appointment rights?
If so, that should be made public.
We know the news has come out today that the Celtic Supporters Limited’s solicitors have written to Celtic PLC to clarify Desmond’s influence over Celtic.
They released the following statement:
CSL’s solicitors have written to Celtic plc. Under Rule 9 of the Takeover Code, anyone whose holding passes 30% normally has to offer to buy out every other shareholder.
In 2005, during Celtic’s share offers, the Takeover Panel waived that requirement, and an undertaking is understood to have been given by Dermot Desmond and/or Line Nominees Limited. The 2005 offer document said the business would continue in substantially the same manner, with no major changes.
That was 21 years ago. On the 16th November our solicitors, Macdonald Henderson, asked the board to confirm: – Whether the undertaking is still in force – Whether it has been changed since 2005 – What its terms say about governance and the protection of minority shareholders – How the board makes sure it is being met
This is a request for clarification, not an accusation. We make no allegation that anyone has breached anything. We have asked for a reply within 14 days, before the AGM on the 1st December.
Every shareholder also has the right to ask the Takeover Panel for its view. You own part of this club. You’re entitled to know the terms it runs under.
Brian McLaughlin from the CSL was on the Trinity Tims last night, and he clarified clearly what their plans are
You can catch the podcast at the bottom of this article.
All of the talk around Rule 9 seems to have awoken a lot people, including myself.
Questions that weren’t being asked before, are starting to be asked now.
One commenter on the podcast scoffed at the fact that this was happening, and asked if anyone thought for a second that this would worry Desmond.
My response was that we had to start somewhere.
Well, we’ve started, so let’s see where it takes us.
Key Takeaways
- Dermot Desmond operates as if he’s the owner of Celtic, despite holding only 34.9% of shares.
- A 34.9% shareholder cannot control day-to-day operations or issue official statements for the company under UK law.
- The current board of Celtic has failed to exercise its independence, allowing Desmond undue influence.
- Ross Desmond, despite rumours of becoming chairman, cannot be appointed without a board vote or majority shareholder consent.
- Questions are emerging about Desmond’s governance and shareholder rights, prompting calls for clarification from the board.
Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.