This morning, I stumbled across a Football Insider story predicting that Celtic are interested in signing John McGinn.
And my first thought wasn’t about McGinn at all.
It was about the fact that the BBC had picked it up and run with it.
Now, let that one sink in for a second.
A supposedly prestigious institution like the BBC, using cyberspace’s worst football website as a source.
Jesus wept.
I think I can safely say that not one Football Insider prediction has ever actually come true
But here they are, at it again, telling us John McGinn could be on his way to Celtic.
Because that’s exactly what we need, isn’t it?
Another thirty-something midfielder to add to the ranks.
The lad is 32, with a contract at Villa Park until 2028, and apparently we’re the club crying out for him.
This gem comes courtesy of former Villa scout Bryan King, speaking “exclusively” to Football Insider.
Here is what he had to say:
Obviously, Everton were interested in him in the summer. Celtic would be interested in him, if he thought about going back to Scotland. He’s still got a good couple of years in him, I think.
Would be interested.
If he thought about it.
A good couple of years.
That’s not a transfer story.
That’s a man guessing out loud, and a website turning the guess into a headline.
How is that fit for anyone to source, never mind the BBC?
Even if he was coming – which he isn’t – where exactly would he fit?
We’re a club that’s supposed to be getting younger, not older.
We’ve spent the last few windows being told the whole model is about sell-on value and resale potential.
So the notion that this same board would sanction a move for a 32-year-old with two years left on his deal, at a fee that would be far from cheap, is laughable.
This is a board that haggles over a million quid like it’s their own money.
The one time they’d move fast is to get a player out the door for a profit, not bring an ageing one in.
So no, the sums don’t add up.
And neither does the story.
The McGinn-to-Celtic saga started nearly nine years ago, and it isn’t ending in some twilight-years fairytale
We all know the history by now.
Celtic reportedly made three bids for him back in 2018, with the final £2 million offer knocked back before Villa came in for £2.75 million.
His grandad was our chairman from 1986 to 1991.
He’s gone on record saying he was desperate to join us.
If he wasn’t my grandpa and I wasn’t a Celtic fan, I probably would be a Celtic player.
It’s a lovely story.
And I get why supporters would love it to be true.
A boyhood Celtic fan, grandson of a former chairman, finally coming home.
It writes itself.
But that ship sailed nearly a decade ago.
The idea that it all ends with McGinn pulling on the Hoops in his twilight years, riding off into the Celtic Park sunset, is the stuff of fan fiction.
It’s not happening.
End of.
And do you know what the funniest part of this whole thing is?
Football Insider have stuck a poll on the story.
You get to vote on whether John McGinn will join Celtic or not.
Brilliant.
Except when you vote in a poll, you tend to expect to see the result of your vote.
Not here.
Here, you click, you get a nice wee “thank you” from Football Insider, and absolutely no idea which way the thing went.
Unless, of course, they decide to publish it at some undisclosed point in the future.
Engagement, I believe they call it.
Or is it just that they don’t fancy the answer they got?
This really has to be the worst football website out there
And the fact that the BBC thinks it’s a credible source is the truly shocking part.
That’s the bit that should worry anyone who still believes the mainstream media does its homework.
Needless to say, we won’t be seeing John McGinn at Celtic.
Not this window, not the next, not ever.
But hey, the very idea of it gets people clicking, doesn’t it?
You see the headline, you go in, you have a read.
And then you realise the whole thing was built on nothing but supposition.
A scout’s maybe, dressed up as a done deal.
Well, that’s Football Insider for you…
Key Takeaways
- The article criticizes the BBC for sourcing a prediction from Football Insider about John McGinn joining Celtic.
- The author doubts the credibility of Football Insider and highlights that their predictions rarely come true.
- McGinn is 32 and under contract at Villa, making a transfer to Celtic seem unlikely and impractical.
- The piece reflects on the long history of McGinn-to-Celtic talks that have never materialised, dismissing them as fan fiction.
- Finally, the article mocks Football Insider’s engagement tactics, particularly their vague polling on McGinn’s potential transfer.
Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.