Colby Donovan is making a strong case for himself at Celtic, and his display against Hearts felt like another step forward.
In a 7-1 win, the young right-back was part of a Celtic side that played with confidence and intensity. He even came close to joining the scorers, sending a powerful effort towards goal after the break that Hearts goalkeeper Beau Reus saved.
That moment summed up the growing confidence in Donovan’s game. He is beginning to look more assured, more consistent and more comfortable at first-team level. There are still raw edges, as you would expect from a young player learning his trade, but the improvement is clear.
Donovan is making the most of his chance
It is easy to focus on what a young player still needs to learn. Donovan deserves credit for what he is already doing: taking his opportunity, competing for his place and showing that he can contribute in a Celtic team with high expectations.
His progress also gives Martin O’Neill a welcome selection decision when Alistair Johnston returns. Johnston brings experience and quality, but Donovan’s performances should make that choice more interesting. The youngster has earned the chance to keep developing and to show how far he can go.
Young players need games to improve
That is the wider point. Young players rarely become finished articles by sitting on the sidelines. They need minutes, trust and the chance to learn from the mistakes that are part of growing into senior football.
Celtic have seen promising defenders struggle to establish themselves amid limited opportunities. Stephen Welsh, Gustaf Lagerbielke and Maik Nawrocki have all had spells where a consistent run of games was hard to come by. Their situations were not identical, but the broader lesson remains: a club cannot properly assess a player without giving him a meaningful chance.
Dane Murray is another young defender who could benefit from opportunities. The more games these players get, the more clearly Celtic can judge their progress and potential.
Celtic should keep backing Donovan
Donovan is not the finished product, and nobody needs to pretend otherwise. He still has development ahead of him. But his improvement is visible, and his performance against Hearts offered another encouraging sign.
Celtic have a talented right-back coming through. With Johnston’s return approaching, competition will increase. Donovan’s job is to keep improving—and Celtic’s job is to give him the opportunity to do it.
He had a good game today for sure…
They might cash in on AJ in January depending on where we are in the league – In fact in all fu**in likelihood they’ll do it anyway…
Colby’s big chance then maybe !
Play AJ as defensive midfeilder , a position we need , he can adapt and has the attributes for that role
I agree give him a run in midfield when johnson comes back
I am sorry but I think Donovan is nowhere near ready, yes he does quite well going forward but his defensive frailties are there for all to see. Maybe Iam getting too old but this type of football as they call it is not good enough. Constantly passing back, it’s like watching rugby go back to go forward. Against Hearts was a bit more like the old Celtic we love and yet when game started it back , back . I thought they were going to open the gates we were going so far back. Then they turned up playing some very nice stuff. Thank you for pleasing an old grumpy fan
Lads got a great engine and physicality. Even when going to ground for a tackle, he makes it more often than not. Has an eye for the early cross and happy to get up and down the wing. I can’t say I’ve ever seen him drop below a 6, steady and consistent but clearly more development to come. I love to see the youth coming through and being given a chance, can’t quite get why we don’t do it more often. Looks like he’ll have a good career, maybe even an excellent one. Doing the jersey proud so far.
Donovan for me personally, has been our best player in recent weeks. Never hides, puts in a great shift and loves a tackle.
This is where we should be backing our own.
Maybe if him amd murray keep their places in will offer more encouragement for our other top youths to stay and fight for first team places.
They will make mistakes but as ling as they keep coming back from it and have learned the lessons it will make them all the better for it.
High hopes for the 2 of them