Hugh Keevins has delivered two sharply different messages about Scottish clubs and European football. When Rangers were already out, continental failure was apparently part of football’s new reality. When Celtic’s Europa League prospects came under scrutiny, Europe suddenly became central to a warning about the club’s future.
The contrast is not imagined. It is there in the veteran columnist’s own words, published less than a month apart.
Rangers’ European exit became a domestic talking point
On 17 October, Keevins wrote in the Daily Record that supporters prioritised domestic rivalry over European achievement. He said repeated European defeats or failure to qualify did not matter much in the long run.
He acknowledged the financial damage caused by Rangers’ absence. However, his central argument was that domestic success mattered more. He even forecast that the Ibrox club would win the Premiership “at a canter”.
One caller, he explained, believed Rangers’ lack of European commitments improved their title chances. Keevins challenged that caller for being too forgiving about the European exit, so he was not offering Rangers an entirely free pass. Nevertheless, the column’s broader message unmistakably played down the lasting significance of continental failure.
Celtic’s European prospects prompt a much darker warning
Fast-forward to 15 November. In another Daily Record column, Keevins turned to Celtic’s board, Martin O’Neill and the impending trip to Portuguese second-tier side Torreense.
He argued that the atmosphere at Celtic’s annual general meeting would depend partly on whether O’Neill’s side remained top of the Premiership and retained a realistic route forward in Europe. Should either ambition fall away, he suggested the manager and boardroom figures would face an extremely uncomfortable meeting.
Nobody is pretending Celtic’s European performances have been acceptable. Serious questions about recruitment, planning and the board’s judgment deserve serious answers. But the argument should not change because the badge on the shirt changes.
Same competition, different measuring stick
Celtic’s 4-1 victory over St Mirren on 21 November kept them at the top of the Premiership. They also remain involved in the Europa League, with UEFA confirming Torreense as their next opponents on 26 November.
Meanwhile, Rangers have no European fixtures at all. Their absence was not a clever strategic decision. It followed elimination in qualifying.
So here is the question Keevins should answer: if failing to qualify for Europe barely matters in the long run, why should Celtic’s continuing European campaign carry such grave consequences for the people running the club?
Celtic supporters are perfectly capable of criticising their own hierarchy. They do not require a lecture on standards. What they are entitled to expect from a national columnist, however, is consistency.
European failure cannot be brushed aside as domestic pragmatism for one club, then presented as an existential warning for the other.
Not without somebody noticing.
Related Read Celtic stories
Celtic are top – so why are Boyd and Keevins talking crisis?
The UEFA rule that could wreck Celtic’s European rescue plan
Key takeaways
- On 17 October, Hugh Keevins argued that European failure mattered less than domestic rivalry.
- His 15 November column made Celtic’s European prospects part of a serious warning about the club’s leadership.
- Celtic remain involved in the Europa League, while Rangers have already been eliminated.
- Supporters deserve consistent scrutiny of both clubs, not different standards depending on the badge.