Auto Draft
Celtic could be preparing to wave goodbye to two of their summer loan signings in January, with Shim Mheuka and Landon Emenalo both facing uncertain futures at Parkhead.
And if either deal is cut short, it would represent another uncomfortable reminder of just how badly Celtic’s summer recruitment has gone.
According to reports, both Chelsea youngsters could be on their way back to Stamford Bridge when the January transfer window opens.
Neither departure has been confirmed, but the lack of first-team opportunities has raised serious questions about why these deals were agreed in the first place.
Let’s look at the numbers.
Mheuka has managed just 80 minutes of first-team football, despite making nine appearances, all from the substitutes’ bench. Emenalo has had even fewer opportunities, recording just 39 minutes across two appearances.
Neither has started a competitive first-team match for Celtic.
There are mitigating circumstances. Emenalo arrived while recovering from injury, while Mheuka has found himself competing with Kasper Høgh, Camilo Durán and Callum Osmand for opportunities.
But that is precisely the point.
Why did Celtic bring these players to Glasgow if there was no clear pathway for them to contribute?
Mheuka arrived with an impressive reputation at Chelsea, having scored 18 goals in 19 Premier League 2 appearances last season. He was supposed to provide another attacking option, but we have barely seen him.
Emenalo was brought in to provide cover at left-back, yet Kieran Tierney has continued to carry the workload while the teenager struggles to get near the starting eleven.
It is difficult to describe either loan as a success.
There is also a wider recruitment issue that Celtic need to address. We have spent another transfer window bringing in players who are either not ready, not trusted or simply not getting the opportunities required to make an impact.
And what makes it even more frustrating is that we have young players of our own waiting for opportunities.
Lucas Clearie has been producing impressive numbers for Celtic B, while other academy prospects are looking for a genuine route into the senior squad.
Instead, we have brought in two Chelsea youngsters who have barely featured.
I have no issue with Celtic using the loan market. It can be an excellent way of bringing quality into the squad without committing significant transfer fees.
But there needs to be a plan.
If Mheuka and Emenalo are going to spend the majority of their time watching from the sidelines, what exactly is the benefit for Celtic or Chelsea?
Both players need regular football to develop, and a move elsewhere in January might be the best outcome for their careers.
However, Celtic must take responsibility for getting these deals wrong.
We cannot keep signing players simply because they are available or come from Premier League academies. We need footballers who address genuine weaknesses in the squad and are capable of contributing when called upon.
If both Chelsea loanees leave in January, it will be another two summer signings who have failed to make a meaningful impression.
And that is simply not good enough for a club with Celtic’s ambitions.