1st November 2026; Falkirk Stadium, Falkirk, Scotland; Scottish Premiership Football, Falkirk versus Celtic; Celtic manager Martin ONeill
I read an article in the Herald this week about the stresses of football management.
And it struck me, almost immediately, just how much pressure Martin O’Neill must be under at Celtic right now.
The piece centres on Ray Power, a Waterford man who has spent the last five years mentoring managers from around the globe, confidentially, through the loneliness of the job.
It’s a fascinating read.
But one line in particular jumped off the page at me.
Big-name managers, the Pep Guardiolas and Jurgen Klopps of this world, will often come out and say, ‘I’m tired, I’m done, I need to take a break’.
Now, just sit with that for a second.
Guardiola is 55.
Klopp walked away from Liverpool at 56 because he said the tank was empty.
Two of the greatest managers of their generation, telling us they were running on fumes.
And then spare a thought for a 74 year old man, hauled out of retirement, to manage a club that carries one of the highest pressure jobs in all of football.
A 74 year old, dragged back into the dugout, and we wonder why he looks jaded
Then take into account the fact that he is also expected to front up and be the spokesman on absolutely everything to do with the club.
Every transfer.
Every injury.
Every boardroom silence he had no part in.
He has to answer for all of it.
So when he looks a bit jaded at a media conference, or sounds a bit incoherent, maybe we should ask ourselves what we’re actually watching.
This is a 74 year old man doing a job that left men 20 years his junior pulling their car over on the way home to cry.
That’s not me being dramatic for effect, by the way.
That’s straight out of the Herald piece.
I have had managers admit to me that they have sat in the car on the way home, pulled over and cried because that was their only private space where they could have that release.
That is the environment Martin O’Neill walked back into.
Now, some will say it’s his own fault, and they’re not entirely wrong
He had no problem taking the job, after all.
He knew exactly what he was getting himself into.
And I’m not going to pretend otherwise.
But we also know there were other circumstances surrounding his reasons for taking it, circumstances that had very little to do with his own ego and a lot to do with the mess the board handed him.
Either way, at times, you can see it takes its toll on the man.
The article focuses on how Brendan Rodgers now helps to mentor other managers through everything he learned, which is admirable.
But here’s the thing.
How on earth could you possibly mentor someone like Martin O’Neill?
A man who has seen it all and done it all before half these coaches were born.
To expect him to be as enthused about the grind as a manager 30 or 40 years his junior is expecting an awful lot.
In fact, O’Neill’s enthusiasm is probably way beyond what it has any right to be for a man of his age.
Power describes the job as a “really macho environment”, one where the man at the top can’t show a crack to anyone.
He can’t take it to the players, because they’re relying on him.
He can’t take it to his staff, for the same reason.
And he can’t take it home, because home is supposed to be separate and sacred.
Now sit with that and tell me a 74 year old is immune to it.
Do I think he should be doing the job?
I’ll stick to the answer I’ve always given on this.
I think he should have walked away a legend after landing the double last May.
I’m sure there are mornings he wakes up and quietly questions himself as to why he ever took on such a pressure-inducing role at this club.
Because there are far too many people out there sharpening their knives in anticipation of a collapse.
And they would be only too happy to hang the whole thing on him as the scapegoat.
Martin O’Neill does not deserve that.
Not a man who gave this club some of the best days of our lives.
But at the same time, if I’m being honest, I can’t help feeling he might have himself to blame too, if things do go south.
Because he knew what he was taking on.
And he knew the pitfalls that came with it.
Every one of us still wants him to leave a legend, but the clock and the climate are against him
We all want him to walk out of Celtic Park with the title secured again this season and his legacy burnished.
Nobody wants that more than me.
But working in such a volatile, poisonous environment, with the Ibrox side and the SMSM circling for any sign of weakness, that may prove a lot harder than anticipated.
Ray Power’s whole point is that these men are not supermen, even if we treat them like they are.
People think elite managers are bulletproof.
They’re not.
Now apply that to a 74 year old doing one of the hardest jobs in the game.
The next few weeks, and into the new year, will tell us an awful lot about the direction of this season…
Key Takeaways
- Martin O’Neill faces immense pressure at Celtic, especially as a 74-year-old managing a high-stress football environment.
- Recent insights highlight the loneliness and high demands placed on football managers, including O’Neill’s role as a spokesman for the club.
- Some critics argue O’Neill chose to take the job, but he also faced external pressures from the board that influenced his decision.
- Expecting O’Neill to maintain the same enthusiasm as younger managers overlooks his vast experience and the toll the role takes on him.
- The volatile nature of football management complicates O’Neill’s legacy, as fans hope for a successful season despite the challenges ahead.
Choose Read Celtic as a ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the news you value.